tinoasprilla

I'd prefer Manquillo to Clark or even Lazar

Playing Gayle *who can't get into West Brom team and Joselu is still a mystery to me and always will be.  Thread should be closed as it will get worse the better he becomes

He needs a run and to be told your in the team for x games.  Even Atsu seems to be ahead in the pecking order

Seems an odd signing personally not convinced but hard to tell from a few minutes here and there

As good as Fernandez has been he will play Lascelles and Lejeune when fit.  Lascelles is still young and likely to improve so makes sense to start him ahead of a 30 year old. I'd like to see more of Schar too

I'd sell Clark and whatever he brings on get a left back a position we've needed to strengthen since Enrique left. 

I still say in a better team who play football he would be an all together improved player.  Yes he has been here a few years but he can still improve whereas fans favourite Ritchie will become even more unathletic

Love how people prefer a player like Ritchie who runs round pointing, leaving his man, hitting the first defender with every cross and the athletic ability of a sloth but he tries. Maybe Perez gets caught on the ball as he literally has no one to pass too and doesn't just pass it backwards for the sake of it. But what do I know! When your playing crap the first players to get criticised are the footballers and not the plodders like Ritchie and Dummett both of who have done fuck all this season

He would be better in a team that tried to play football

Rob Lee in his prime someone who will support and run beyond the striker

It's like having Jack Colback with tipped hair on the wing

Agree all three are solid defensively but as a team if they are part of the reason we can't function or retain the ball it needs to change.  Agree again though that it won't

Shelvey plays deep because Lascelles, Fernandez and Dummett can't pass the ball.  We massively miss Lejeune. I'd give Schar a chance instead of fernandez or lascelles or we might as well be playing Shelvey as a sweeper

I thought him and Shelvey were our best players by a mile

 

hardly were given a run for their money were they?

No agree but those two are literally our only hope going forward.

I thought him and Shelvey were our best players by a mile

Hits the first defender with his crosses way too often.  Takes awful set pieces.  Points and shouts a lot which is mistaken for effort.  In the team as we have no one else

There is a complete lack of confidence in the team.  Lejeune is a huge miss the back four can't pass the ball.  Ritchie runs arou d pointing and shouting but does nothing.  The crowd love him though as he runs round pointing and shouting.  His set pieces were awful never missed the front man.  Shelvey sprayed a 60 yard pass leaving him one on one and he turned inside knocking it twenty yards back.  We are woeful only shelvey and Kennedy have My creation. Our bench is dire this can only go one way

I've got hope back after yesterday. Benitez needs to play strongest team every week no tinkering. Lascelles and shelvey need to stay fit get Lejeune back sign Messi in January we will be sweet. Oh and Ashley to die of asphyxiation after stuffing too many sausage rolls down his fat neck at Christmas

When he broke in the second half and failed to pass it seven yards to Shelvey. You could see exactly what was going to happen before it did.  Tragically bad. I can't believe Aaron's or Roberts didn't deserve a chance ahead of this guy

Really like him needs to be in the team every week and should have been in before now

Just doesn't look like a footballer him and atsu were awful. Ashley to blame our bench was woeful

I think he just went for his weekly hand job from Lee Charnley

My dad is 71 and been going for more than 60 years.  He used to go watch them train we would go up benwell every Saturday morning in the 80s to watch the youths.  Now he won't set foot in St James Park as in his view this is the worst it's ever been.  That's what Ashley is doing to people. Ashley flogs tickets in the Universities and Colleges cheaply.  The people going to the match have changed and apathy rules

None.  Needs an 80s style riot

Take fucking joselu off

Brilliant sub! Not rafas fault though

Almost as sick of Benitez as I am Ashley which is ridiculous.  Why did he buy Schar or Muto or Murphy?  Yet Joselu plays every week ?