Yeah I agree, the problem with female commentators is they are often under-qualified and make daft comments (which some of the men do as well) and it feels like they've been appointed because they're female rather than because they are football experts, with an interesting opinion and the ability to translate that into commentary. I didn't get that at all from the woman last night, I thought she was good, more than happy to have her commentating on games. I guess it's personal preference though, I don't mind Carragher either.