Honest assessment of our squad ...

[mrmojorisin75]

the title was honest assessment of the squad - i'd take that to mean players that can stay at the club for say 4-5 years+ and be successful in improving our situation (albeit not immediately) coupled with the addition of new players, thus:

 

Established and good enough -

Given

Harper

Parker (needs better coaching and a defined role in the team, however)

N'Zogbia

Milner

Taylor (again needs to be coached better and have a settled, experienced partner brought in)

Martins

Owen

Ameobi (as back up, he's equally the equivalent of Mido at spurs for 4th choice for example)

 

Unproven but look like they have enough potential and therefore should be kept -

Edgar

Huntington (obviously not at fullback any more though)

Krul

(the likes of Carroll, Lua Lua etc... can't be judged from a first team perspective right now but may end up being good enough who knows?)

 

i don't include Butt/Solano/Sib maybe as i'd see them staying one more season each and being replaced naturally over the course of things...EVERYONE else i'd sell on the first day of the transfer window this year

 

that is a BRUTALLY honest assessment of the squad

[juniatmoko]

Keep:

 

Given

Harper

Krul

 

Solano

Taylor

Gooch

Edgar

Huntington

 

Milner

Emre

Butt

N'zogbia

Pattison

Dyer

 

Owen

Martins

Ameobi

 

Sell:

 

Bramble

Moore

Babayaro

Carr

Parker

Duff

 

 

 

Sell DUFF and PARKER but keep PATTISON? ok

 

Pattison is 20 and on a low wage. You could probably have 30 Pattisons for Parkers wage!

 

Id rather have no Pattison and no wages. Agree with Parker and Duff just seemed a strange decision.

 

Keep:

 

Given (legend.. best thing we had at NUFC)

Harper (back up)

Krul (back up)

 

Solano (good back up... need another replacement which younger)

Taylor (i still believe he got his potential... so don't be crap again)

Gooch (haven't seen enough from him)

Edgar (got potential)

Huntington (got potential but u must proved next year or you must out)

 

Milner (one of the best performer this season.. need to play more)

Emre (the best ACM we had at the moment)

Butt (better DM than parker)

N'zogbia (come on zoggy .. show you really are again)

Duff (his impact doesn't suited his high wages i want to give another season for him btw.)

 

 

 

Owen (when on his day he is absolute finisher... but now crock... but i still have high hopes on him)

Martins (good poacher ... need to be consistent more)

Dyer (come on he is not RW at all... can't cross to save his life)

Le sib (good back up consider we don't have target man)

 

Sell:

 

Bramble (genuinely shit)

Moore (old crap)

Babayaro (if we don't get rid of you... glenn will still playing you)

Carr (bald cunt)

Parker (he doesn't have role in the way team play beside he is our beloved captain... only suitable for 4-3-3 formation not 4-4-2 the way we playing)

Pattison (completed shit)