The whole thing with Given is that he left in January. It's as simple as that.
Thie situation as a whole is not that simple though. Had it been someone like Owen, Martins, Barton, etc., then it would be that simple
Surprised at the amount of dislike for Given. The guy stayed with us through far more than almost any player of his caliber would have. I'd like to see a Villa/Man City final, with any kind of result.
Seriously, Palacios, just quit.