Unbelievable

It was in context! The boy has been piss poor all season. Just asked Baggio for a rating! Personally, I can't think of anyone deserving of a lower mark. Baggio could. What would you give him for his 'performances' this season? It wasn´t in context. Milner hadn´t been mentioned once and this thread is about the new signings, so not sure what Milner´s got to do with that.. Course it was. Smith got a one and Milner has been worse. Hence, I asked Baggio what he would have got. Baggio answered without a quibble! Good lord, Spottys lovers are getting tetchy now they have realised how s*** he is Thing is, you´re probably the only one who thinks Milner has been worse than Smith so far this season. Do you want everybody to ask Baggio what mark the player they dislike would have got? I will now stop being OT, it´s something I don´t like and there are unfortunately a few people on here who are experts in it..

It was in context! The boy has been piss poor all season. Just asked Baggio for a rating! Personally, I can't think of anyone deserving of a lower mark. Baggio could. What would you give him for his 'performances' this season? It wasn´t in context. Milner hadn´t been mentioned once and this thread is about the new signings, so not sure what Milner´s got to do with that..

Allardyce - 6 has strengthened the squad with a focus on the defence, something that was badly needed. The injury record of the club seems to have improved overall, which I'll give him some credit for. Tactically suspect so far however, seemingly unable to decide on a system and making too conservative choices in midfield (4 central midfielders, out of which 3 are defense-minded in a 4-4-2, 3 defensive midfielders in a 3-man midfield). We should have been higher up after the relatively easy start. Next weeks against better opposition could make or break him, but for now we need the stability so here's hoping the results and performances pick up quickly Beye - 5,5 an average start to his Newcastle career. Still adjusting to the pace of the Premiership of course. Disappointed by his attacking contribution so far.. Enrique - 6,5 solid, but not spectacular. Still young and adjusting. Our only left back with Babayaro seemingly permanently crocked, so here's hoping he stays fit.. Faye - 7 decent start. Providing us with some much needed physicality in central defence. Decent at set pieces too. Viduka - 6,5 has shown glimpses of what he can do and scored some important goals and shown some good technical skill (through balls etc). Unfortunately for us very injury prone. Barton - 5 injured in preseason, and on current evidence has been brought back in too early, because he has been very average for a player of his quality. Will hopefully come good, because we badly need an in-form Barton. Rozehnal - 7 good start and has settled quickly. Still a little concerned about his lack of physical presence, but so far so good. Cacapa - 6,5 made a good start, but definately seems a player who may be useable or not depending on the opposition strikeforce. A very natural, intelligent defencer but perhaps past his peek and his lack of pace makes him a liability against strong, pacy strikers.. Smith - 5 did not understand this signing and haven´t seen much to suggest I was wrong. Adds nothing in midfield and is just average in forward positions. Hard working, but an absolute lack of creativity, plus he´s a liability with his (late) tackling. A ridiculous amount of bookings already, and a sending off seems just around the corner whenever he plays. Geremi - 6 a decent start, and I think he would do better more centrally (Butt´s current position). Disappointed with his set plays, which is supposedly something he was once good at..

We've played the easy games, some tough ones coming up. We are in midtable and playing badly. Seems like the honneymoon period is definately over..

1-0 Spurs..

Very worrying indeed..

This is so ridiculous it's almost funny.. We're hard to beat at home, supposedly...

what the hell is this? 2-0 already?!

2-2 FT. Good match!

2-2 Walcott, correction: Gallas..

Evra almost scored a great own goal..

2-1 Ronaldo. Good goal..

great free kick position. Van Persie would have relished this..

1-1 Fabregas

Oh bugger.. What was the goalkeeper doing there.. Have to hand it to them though.. Edit: deflection. Not much Almunia could do tbf..

Howard Webb is Man U's 12th man..

Close, very close..

Have Man U made a successful pass yet?

Must be watching a different game. Missed the first five minutes tbh, but since then Arsenal have looked the most dangerous by far.. Are you still talking? Are you still watching another game..? Man U is getting raped out there..

Howard Webb is giving everything Man U's way and still Alex Ferguson is protesting..

Evra will not see the final whistle I think.. Ferguson will have him subbed long before then..

How can Evra claim that wasn't a foul..?

Should have been a pen..

Must be watching a different game. Missed the first five minutes tbh, but since then Arsenal have looked the most dangerous by far..

Wasn't offside that was it..? He was played onside by the other DC wasn't he?