Martins has done little wrong. He's looked quite good - got himself into proper winger's positions, helped Beye out quite a lot and Butt/Milner have picked him out a couple of times. I wouldn't be surprised to see him score today, Martins.
Smith's not done much at all imo.
Smith does a lot it's just that when he goes near the ball people shut their eyes.
Strange how people can view things so differently. I'm with Yorkie on this one: Martins has done relatively well playing as a right winger. Smith hasn't done anything at all. I'm not even sure what his position is supposed to be and what he is supposed to contribute..