Jump to content

Kid Icarus

Member
  • Posts

    16,746
  • Joined

Posts posted by Kid Icarus

  1. Just now, et tu brute said:


    And here are the sheep

    Ironically people like you all sound the same when you use that word.

  2. The big calls tonight for me were Joelinton and Pope and you're ultimately defined by the result regardless of which decision you make. Pope especially should have been a no-brainer if he's fit.

  3. Extremely disappointing result obviously. A real shame after the flow we were in pre-Brighton that it's ended like this. 7th or 8th looking very likely now, which is still an achievement considering the difficulties of this season, but no less raw and disappointing.

  4. Dubravka: 3.5

    Trippier: 4.5

    Krafth: 6

    Burn: 6

    Hall: 8.5

    Bruno: 6.5

    Longstaff: 5

    Anderson: 6

    Murphy: 6

    Isak: 5

    Gordon: 7.5

     

    Extremely disappointing result obviously. A real shame after the flow we were in pre-Brighton that it's ended like this. 7th or 8th looking very likely now, which is still an achievement considering the difficulties of this season, but no less raw and disappointing.

  5. 1 minute ago, Andy said:

     

    See it feels the opposite to me, I feel like there's a dodgy decision almost every single game of football I watch. Aye it's nice when it goes in your favour, but even then I'm not sure it's worth it. 

    Just in general or through VAR?

  6. 2 minutes ago, Andy said:

    I don't believe anyone can watch a game of football and find it more enjoyable with VAR than without, and that's the crux of the issue really. There are so many issues with it that stand in the way of spectacle - not being able to celebrate goals, play being stopped for minutes on end while they go to the far end of a fart to try to find a reason to overturn something, and most importantly, blatantly incorrect decisions still being made at the end of it all anyway.

     

    The human elements will never be removed for the majority of decisions. I'd rather the human element just be "referee or linesman fuck up", at least then you can say "well they only seen it once". It's far more annoying when they still fuck up having watched an incident 99 times over. 

     

    Things like the pantomime of sending the ref to the screen, and the shit in-stadium communication make it even worse. 

     

    If automated offside is fast and works well, then use that. Everything else, put in the bin. 

    As a neutral definitely, but I find it more enjoyable when Newcastle aren't shafted by a shit decision because VAR comes to the rescue. It's not perfect, when wrong decisions are still made with VAR it's even worse, but it does feel rarer.

×
×
  • Create New...