Newcastle United 2-1 Southampton - 8/12/19

[Greg]

Did anyone else think the Southampton goal was offside? Only saw the one replay at the time but it looked like Ings was off when the ball was launched forward and no-one touched it before he latched onto it?

There is an angle that makes it look like he’s offside. Disappointed MOTD didn’t take another look at it to clarify it.

 

He literally overtook Fernandez after the ball was played, not even close.

[Tsunami]

Did anyone else think the Southampton goal was offside? Only saw the one replay at the time but it looked like Ings was off when the ball was launched forward and no-one touched it before he latched onto it?

There is an angle that makes it look like he’s offside. Disappointed MOTD didn’t take another look at it to clarify it.

 

He literally overtook Fernandez after the ball was played, not even close.

 

VAR checked it, Ref delayed the restart while it was checked.

[John P]

Did anyone else think the Southampton goal was offside? Only saw the one replay at the time but it looked like Ings was off when the ball was launched forward and no-one touched it before he latched onto it?

There is an angle that makes it look like he’s offside. Disappointed MOTD didn’t take another look at it to clarify it.

 

He literally overtook Fernandez after the ball was played, not even close.

 

When the ball is played he's offside relative to Fernandez (which is why I thought he was off when I saw the first replay), but Schar on the far side looks like he's just playing him on, which I didn't see at the time. It is close though.

[Greg]

Did anyone else think the Southampton goal was offside? Only saw the one replay at the time but it looked like Ings was off when the ball was launched forward and no-one touched it before he latched onto it?

There is an angle that makes it look like he’s offside. Disappointed MOTD didn’t take another look at it to clarify it.

 

He literally overtook Fernandez after the ball was played, not even close.

 

When the ball is played he's offside relative to Fernandez (which is why I thought he was off when I saw the first replay), but Schar on the far side looks like he's just playing him on, which I didn't see at the time. It is close though.

 

Nah.

[John P]

Did anyone else think the Southampton goal was offside? Only saw the one replay at the time but it looked like Ings was off when the ball was launched forward and no-one touched it before he latched onto it?

There is an angle that makes it look like he’s offside. Disappointed MOTD didn’t take another look at it to clarify it.

 

He literally overtook Fernandez after the ball was played, not even close.

 

When the ball is played he's offside relative to Fernandez (which is why I thought he was off when I saw the first replay), but Schar on the far side looks like he's just playing him on, which I didn't see at the time. It is close though.

 

Nah.

 

Ja

https://imgur.com/mJDZgoS

[Greg]

Did anyone else think the Southampton goal was offside? Only saw the one replay at the time but it looked like Ings was off when the ball was launched forward and no-one touched it before he latched onto it?

There is an angle that makes it look like he’s offside. Disappointed MOTD didn’t take another look at it to clarify it.

 

He literally overtook Fernandez after the ball was played, not even close.

 

When the ball is played he's offside relative to Fernandez (which is why I thought he was off when I saw the first replay), but Schar on the far side looks like he's just playing him on, which I didn't see at the time. It is close though.

 

Nah.

 

Ja

https://imgur.com/mJDZgoS

 

I stand corrected.

[Kanj]

Seemed strange positioning anyway that Schar was sucked into that left side and Dummett was pushed up. Willems was also sort of in no man's land too.

[Tsunami]

That’s a very poor line they’re trying to hold.

[huss9]

bruce fucked up the central defensive line.