Flip

I'd have him in a heartbeat for £15 million. Sorry but if Carroll worth £35 then hes worth £15. Well at least now when Carroll has signed for Liverpool.

sorry, but if this happens I'd be so happy. This kid might be a retard, but he's fucking talented. Carroll didn't prove out to be what we thought he was.

Like someone said, the next transfer windows

Dempsey would be huge in this team. Great great player. Just dont know where to fit him with Ireland in the team now.

Funny if he signed, then played shit and got sold back to us for £10 million

£35 million for arguably a player who is top 5 at the club. The only thing on his side is age, but I mean he hasn't performe 100x times better than Jose Enrique, Coloccini, Tiote, Barton and Ben Arfa (for the one or two games he played) Funny if Ben Arfa is worth £5 million and Carroll £35 million. Its just fucking ridiculous.

Remember when Zidane in his prime was sold for less than double of what Carroll is going for.

Wonder how Nolan feels? If he feels stabbed in the back or if he's fine with this.

I would have been gutted if he was only sold, but handing in a transfer request just worsens the situation. Fucking knobhead if it's true. Ill wait till everything has materialized though.

£40 + Crouch I hope. (by saying hope I dont really hope for it to happen, but if it does happen I hope it £40 million at least.) Lets get this bidding start going. Lets get as much as possible, if we now are to sell him.

That's the thing, it's such a risk. But I guess Ashley isn't taking the risk of getting relegated and those £40 million becoming worth shit.

I think that is Ashley's thinking. You're getting £50m for Torres, we want the lot He's a business man, Ashley knows exactly what he's doing. He's waiting till the last hour to sell him for £50 and Torres staying in Liverpool as Chelsea pull out and they get bankrupt.

hahahahaha, I'm so happy even though £40 million was huge sum. Hahahaha GREAT!

We dont and I agree. But if the football markets inflation goes back to a healthy level and clubs realise it then he will most likely to never be worth that much. It's just ridiculous how he cant be bought for that kind of money.

Mate this is the biggest mugging in football history. I get that he's vital for you lot but from a neutrals perspective, you've done them over big time. i for once agree with you. That money is ridiculous, he's nowhere near that value but then again I still be gutted if he leaves. Shrewd piece of business though.

We got Ganso, Alexis Sanchez and Neymar in line to sign instead. Derek llambias is as we speak in Italy, Peru and brazil at the same time. Great guy, what a legend.

I was, read my OP. But I see do also see it as a concern as I doubt Shola, Best, Ranger or Loven will get us loads of goal. We have had to rely on Nolan to get goals earlier without Carroll.

I think we need at least 3 more of you. You should follow matta here below, PM him for examples on how to post something that's on topic. Rather than criticizing. If you don't like it ignore, if the moderators think it unnecessary they'll delete it later.

We don't have 100 threads about this. And I also raised the subject because it seems it was very divided in the other thread. But if people think its pointless delete the thread then. Couldn't give a fuck, back to the unorganized discussion in the Andy Carroll thread then like.

I'd be gutted if he does leave, but that money is just crazy. And if our goals are to stay and we are going to stay up without him, what's hindering us from letting him leave? I be gutted because with him I think we can finish top 10 this season, without him, we're in a relegation battle.

It's a genuine concern, I'm of the thought that for that money he should be sold, but many in the Carroll bid thread are saying we're back to the Championship and while I think we're not a one man team many are.

Genuine question. If he does leave and we don't get anyone in. Will we stay up? Will Shola, Best, Lovenkrands and Rangers be able to provide goals for the rest of the season? This is a genuine concern, I don't value Carroll at £35 million, but right now with no replacement in he shouldn't be sold and we should take our chances on developing him further. But what if we have no one? Will we stay up? Edit: To make this post clearer for everyone, I'm of the belief we will stay up without him in the team. However, many think we won't in the Andy Carroll thread and therefore I raised this subject.

There is no press conference.

Would you guys take this, unrealistic but still, Im fucking dreaming already I hope Barton - Tiote - Nolan Ganso Ben Arfa Neymar Sextastic

haha of course he can.