toptoon

Roeder messed up huge time yesterday in team selection. Can we blame Roeder for shambles's mistakes ? yes we bloody can because he bloody picked him when most of us woulden't have and Nobby, car aswell and HE is responsible for our defenive personel (which is not acceptable). Ramage bar the glaring miss was actually pretty decent and as for some trying to make Emre our scapegoat, they must be off their rockers as he was probably our best player. Roeder (for his team selection, tactically and half time talk), bramble, car and solano were particularly bad yesterday.

LUQUE HAS BEEN TOTAL DOGSHIT SINCE HE CAME HERE. (just not suited to the Prem unfortunately like Viana) SHOLA HAS SCORED A GOAL EVERY OTHER GAME UNDER ROEDER AND MADE BIG CONTRUBUTIONS TO OUR TEAM. Long may this continue.

Drop him into the reserves until we can sell him, if he's good enough for them i'm not sure.

You may well be right, but lets wait and see. I trust Glenn to get this right and i dont think Glenn will take any crap from Luque either. Maybe its innocent and we are over analysing things. I'm not a big Luque fan at all and personally i'd sell him if we got a decent price for him i.e. around £6m. But if he's desperate to impress maybe Glenn will give him another shot.

Nail on head for me!

I'd have him for £10m deffinately now!!! Great little player, so quick!!

No way he's a crock! That knee injury keeps re-occuring stay well clear last thing we need is another Dyer. Time for either one or two of Tuncay, Kuyt, Gudjohnsson, Van Nilstelrooy, Defoe, Collins John, Jerrome, etc

Roeder has obviously had a very positive effect on him and he's played great since Glen's been in charge so credit where credit is due well done Shola he's been instrumental in getting us back into Europe.

Chuffed to bits if he does, between them they have really worked wonders for us! didn't rate Roeder after he took west ham down but if Hitzfeld o'nelil etc had us winning 9 out if 13 premiership games alot of people would be creaming their pants on here, proclaiming they had worked miracles. so full credit where credit's due to the pair of them. i would have been gutted if he hadn't got the job! my one fear though is that once Shearer leaves glen on his own things may take a downturn, so far they have worked wonders as a Team, so i really hope shearer stays on too. Imo i'd much preffer Shearer and Roeder, two people who geniunely love, care and know the club inside out over some mercenary who has no ties with the club whatsover. In Roeders short spell in charge of our team he has been fantastic and i hope he is installed as manager given a two year contract with 2 year optional extension and starts on the same wages as Souness.

I thought the same as you up untill the Everton game (when i didn't think we could play any worse)! However last night we went way lower! He is now on borrowed time IMO unless he can pull things round pretty sharpish! Not only are we not getting the results but we are playing very poorly and don't deserve them alot of the time! A realistic position after our terrible start was 6th (which should be a UFEA spot) even FF has stated so, we can of course still make that but if we lose against villa at home or he doesn't do well up to xmas then we should look at replacing him with someone better if possible! He has to take the blame with the players for that performance last night!