Jump to content

Memphis

Member
  • Posts

    2,080
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Memphis

  1. Cannot even imagine the thought process behind a statement like that. How someone thought that would help matters is beyond belief.

     

    I can only hope for his sake Pardew's name was signed to this without his knowledge; otherwise, he's complicit by allowing himself to be perceived in this bootlicking, ass-kissing style.  It's pitiful.

  2. I suppose, then, it's a pipe dream to look at the squad in place as a platform upon which to build.

     

    Clearly some of the likes of Tiote and Jonas can be improved upon even if they're not bolded/italicised/struck through. Beyond that, there is simply a massive leadership vacuum in place that is sucking the life out of the supporters through continued flagging ambition. Considering the state of the competition and the amount of money available, there is - at least in my mind - an obligation to at least try to make the squad stronger. To show some ambition. To at least pretend to try to win something, even if that's a long way from happening.  That's what Southampton/Norwich/West Ham/Everton, etc are doing, and they've at least given their supporters a sign they're interested in trying to get better.

     

    Effective depth in our case wouldn't have been all that expensive, considering some of the signings that were made in the window.

     

    So, back to Kinnear, then. His appointment served to seal our fate as a bobbing ship content to stay afloat and hope that by dint of good fortune or whatever that we'd somehow move forward in the Premier League ocean. And I suppose we might. But it's happening in a way that's deflating energy and excitement and slowly shrinking the fan base. Don't know how that approach is defensible.

     

     

  3. Most of the ones you've highlighted as fringe players are fringe players.

     

    Correct. As I mentioned.

     

    The point is that they stand a very real chance of being forced into significant playing time due to injury concerns. The strength in depth - as has been pointed out billions of times previous - is nonexistent. So any injuries, which are inevitable particularly with our luck, will be even more troublesome than is needed.

     

    It is not a strong squad at all. There are good players, but not nearly enough of them, and that is the point.

  4. Posted something similar a day or to - our squad on paper. I fail to see how anyone can be disappointed with the squad we start this season with as a club that finished 16th in the league last year.

     

    GK - Krul, Elliot, Alnwick

     

    DEF - Debuchy, Yanga-Mbiwa, Coloccini, Santon, Williamson, S. Taylor, Haidara, R. Taylor, Dummett, Tavernier, Good

     

    MID - Ben Arfa, Sissoko, Anita, Cabaye, Tiote, Gutierrez, Marveaux, Gosling, Obertan, Bigirimana, Ameobi, Amalfitano

     

    ATT - Cisse, Remy, Gouffran, Ameobi, Vuckic

     

    I've taken the liberty of placing in bold the players who have continuing injury concerns - and all of whom have missed significant time recently with said injuries.

     

    I've italicized the players who are or clearly should be fringe players, who are either unproven or proven to be not at the level a "top 10" team needs to be playing on a regular basis.

     

    I've struck through the players who are just not good enough at this level.

     

    I don't think your statement is very compelling.

  5. At the end, our fullbacks were so attacking it almost looked like:

     

                                              Krul

     

                                MYM                    Colo

     

    Debuchy                        Cabaye                          Santon

     

                                      Sissoko

     

    HBA                                                                    Gouffran

     

                                                    Remy

     

                                Cisse

×
×
  • Create New...