Having watched a few Bundesliga games, I thought I preferred it with the fake crowd noise but I think it works much less well in the Premier League.
Most well-attended German games, the noise of the crowd is constant, a permanent kind-of drumbeat and unless there's a goal, there's actually not that much noticeable reaction to the events on the field.
English football's not like that, it's much more passive and quiet when the game's just going on with nothing much happening but then much more vociferous in reaction to anything, a tackle, a chance. The fake crowd noise doesn't work at all here, it sounds ridiculous.