STM

A disappointing window according to some but that's because we didn't sign the players in the position THEY prioritised.

Honestly, Villa look a mile more appealing than Spurs, for example. Much more balance and depth. Neither us nor Villa should be finishing below Spurs. It's a real bone of contention for me that anyone can think Spurs have a better first team or squad than either of us.

It was 2 more including Livramento, who he obviously didn't want to be drawn on.... although he said he liked the player so that's as good as done.

We are better than Spurs and therefore should be getting more than what they get. Let them cry.

Erudite.

It's a good question. Heard various conflicting things....

It's also that "pace" people have been asking for.

It can't be understated how important it is that we are signing versatile players: Gordon RW, LW, 10, ST Barnes RW, LW, 10 Tonali, DM, CM Livramento RB, LB, RW? We aren't signing one position, we are covering a range of areas.

Interesting that Livramento seems a very different type to Trippier. Where as Trippier wants to dink passes or play in triangles, this lad looks to want to burst past players. Another physical specimen. Good stuff.

Seems we are probably suffering a 5m tax on the young English players we are signing. Gordon = 40m Barnes = 33m Livramento = 30/35m Would have all been much more accurate prices for position and age of said players. It's been a looooooong time since Newcastle United have started hoovering up quality British/Irish players and I'm all for it. Let's hope we aren't done.

Timing

I think we will sign Livramento and that will be it.

Was actually quite funny.

Any suggestions as to who we could get?

Yeah that's my issue here. This narrative that Dan Burn is a poor left back. He was probably top 3/4 left backs in the league last year. Unless we are signing someone like Joao Cancelo or Theo Hernandez, I really don't see the issue. I'd rather wait for a proper world class left back who would instantly improve us, than take a punt on players who might be better going forward. The "going into games against real madrid" arguement is a daft one too. Literally cherry picking the hardest side in Europe we could face. If that's the case, we need a new right back too because Trippier might struggle with Vini Jr.

I don't want us finishing below Spurs and Villa. Therefore 6th place is the target. Chelsea and Man United should be in our sights too.

Right?

All I read there is; "If we don't sign the players I want, I won't be happy." We HAVE improved. We ARE improving. We are MILES ahead of where anyone with half a brain thought we would be. We don't have a perfect 11 or squad is what you are basically saying, which is absurd.

I don't necessarily disagree with you but it's not clear cut and that confirms my point about Spurs.

It's such a simple concept. It's getting painful having to point this stuff out. We are ahead of ourselves.

Depends if you know what context is.

Fair but he's not the player people think he is. Miggy was better than him last season.

This thread just shows, no matter how exceptional your success has been and how far your club has come, some people just aren't happy and never will be. Give certain individuals the opportunity to be negative rather than positive and they will always choose the former and then hide behind "just telling it how it is". We finished 4th last year and have improved. There's absolutely nothing to say we won't finish top 6 this year. Which, for me, would be a good season.

I don't think beyond their first team, they have a strong squad at all (Man Utd), I don't think their signings improve them much at all. As for Spurs.... Kane is an exceptional player, of course but I don't rate many of their squad at all. Son isn't the player he was. Bentancur is a good player. I wouldn't swap any of our defenders or midfielders for theirs. I'd rather have Villa's squad than Spurs.

Completely disagree with everything you've said but then I normally do.