SUPERTOON

Is he not more a DM?

In terms of ability? Cabaye? More the overall package he brings.

All those happy to see him leave, assuming that we actually replace him, have you got any ideas who we could get that is better than Nolan?

Apart from this isn't Pardew's decision.

Weird isn't it, you'd think he'd scored 30 goals for us from centre midfield in the last 2 seasons or something.

How is it clear?

Where is Brummie at?

Aside from mentioning Guitierrez not too much to disagree with there. (Unless Enrique also has a sudden change of heart and signs up). You could disagree about slating Nolan for the Stevenage game. Cup upsets happen all the time, are we really going to judge his Newcastle career and the reasons for selling him on one game.

Not much to disagree with there. Tbh, when people praise Shola they are joking.

Any more on this since 20 pages ago?

There would be no point in selling him to replace him with someone similar.

Pretty much.

What does Nolan offer that Gardner doesn't? They are almost the same, Nolan scores more and is already here. Why sell Nolan for him, if indeed we are?

Must be the favourite, Pards seems to like him.

What it being looked at is we have sold our captain, top goalscorer and leader for peanuts, when he didn't want to leave and had two years on his deal left.

£4m is the reported fee, I think. Doubt West Ham would have upped to £4m from £1.5m in a couple of days, mind. More likely to be paid in installments.

So we missed him by default as his replacement was Alan Smith. If he isn't replaced, surely it is a fair argument, going into next season?

Or Stephen Ireland.

Can't wait for the Pardew response tomorrow, the usual crap of us being close to signing some really good players, then on deadline day Ireland is back on loan.

Hello Jonny,spoke a day to soon. Almost on par with Gyan leaving?

End the thread here. There is nothing more to say. Surely either way, it will have a massive impact?

Care to expand?

Imagine that