Ronaldo

So you agree that Taylor is one of the worst defenders in the Premiership then? Come off it, he's not great by any means but he's far from one of the worst. no, I never said that, I said that I agreed that he's 'vastly overrated and inferior to cacapa' If you could sort premiership defenders in four categories he'd probably be in the lower middle section. Sadly that's where he's been for the last four years. I honestly dont see any solid improvement

Load of bollocks he's right about Taylor though, vastly overrated and an inferior defender to Cacapa Who overrates him? Seriously? I really want to know the answer to that question. This tripe about him being let off cos he's young and cos he's a Geordie. As far as i can see, on here anyway, he's rated evenly. Decent player, has potential, but pretty limited in a few departments. Can anyone really disagree with that? Agree that Caçapa is better though. on here i would say about 60% overrate him. In the pubs in town about 70% consider him a good defender. Dont even get me started about the rest of the country who seem to think he's our best defender. And the fucking media, jesus, you'd think he was the next Rio Ferdinand

Load of bollocks he's right about Taylor though, vastly overrated and an inferior defender to Cacapa

good I guess, because he's better than Edgar. Still hope we sign one or two solid CB's so he gets nowhere near

it's the Villa game that annoys me most when people talk about Cacapa. Again and again he got Taylor out of trouble or did his work yet people tried to put the opposite spin on it, honestly. Faye and Cacapa generally looked by far our most solid partnership last season

very harsh

Nope you're wrong. Bentley said he wants to play "European football". He said champions league first, then said "well at least Europe" which in a way, is a come and get me plea. you're dreaming pal, a pal of mine met Bentley a month back in Malia, Liverpool is the only place he wants to go

goal and a half to be fair

continues to improve? has the world gone mad? when has he improved, he's the same player he was 3 years ago I can't understand how you see no improvement. Do you know what it takes to be a good centre back? too right i do, i've played CB all my life. Taylor is the same, slow, rash, misjudging defender he was under Souness, how can you see an improvement? at least a quarter of the goals we've conceded this season can be attributed to him, Everton (a) last game was a key example, Horrific defending

continues to improve? has the world gone mad? when has he improved, he's the same player he was 3 years ago

prized assets my chod

Although he is in Africa to promote his football foundation, so fair's fair. Should be banged up with Barton.... if you believe any of that, you should be banged up in funny farm

got to be honest though, our midfield is certainly not good enough to finish top half

I think Cacapa could do a decent job in a settled defence. That injury he had that kept him out of the Man City game seemed to knacker him up and then when he played against Pompey he was carrying an injury and never recovered as all people remember now is that game. It really annoys me when you see him on the Prems worst transfer lists. You can tell the people that make them watch 1 maybe 2 games if you're lucky. I agree man, with the exception of Portsmouth, Cacapa and Faye looked very solid together

you're an idiot

very much so, it sickened me that

no real weak link? look at the back 5 pal, that central defence isn't good enough if we want to challenge Everton, Portsmouth, City etc

four good defenders is overstating it a little bit, 1 good, 3 average to be honest

depressing, very depressing

£5M would be a steal tbh like him but just about the worst winger i've ever seen at the club that regularly gets in

yep that's pretty much the litmus test, ask them what they think of Enrique then ask them what they think of Taylor

why would he go to Man City, really, they're going absolutely nowhere with that dickhead in charge

yeah, if he could run and wanted to be here he'd be perfect

mackems.gif ?

nowt personal mate, just i literally cannot believe some of your views, each to their own anyway