Jump to content

Geordie Ahmed

Member
  • Posts

    14,809
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Geordie Ahmed

  1. How "close" were you to sign PEA? Did you actually table an offer?

     

    According to St Etienne we did but the player wanted Dortmund, once Dortmund wanted him we never had a hope really.

     

    Probably was so after he went on that goalscoring run 2nd half of last season.

     

    Unlucky St Ettienne got to the cup final otherwise think we could have got him in Jan

  2. That goal still gives me a hard on.

     

    The amount of idiots who claimed at the time that "its not that good, he only runs in a straight line" :lol:  Completely missing the balance required, the split second change of pace to get away from the second tackle and the little chip while running flat out at the end to leave the last defender tackling thin air.

     

    It was mainly Mackems that downplayed the goal

     

    It was quality

    1) The initial turn to leave the defender on his backside

    2) Brushes off Davies attempt to chop him down with a little funny run

    3) The perfect and subtle little dink which left the defender kicking air

    4) The finish

     

     

     

  3. I think McCarthy is decent enough at what he does, but that article said Wigan were looking for £20m. For that sort of money, you'd want a player with a better touch on the ball than McCarthy has got IMO. His passing looks quite conservative as well.

     

    I'd prefer him to Tiote though.

     

    I think McCarthy has a fantastic touch and his passing is one of his strong points, admittedly not as good as Cabaye's passing BUT he can pass players which is something Cabaye struggles with

     

    A good player who would be a top signing

  4. I think Cleverley is a good player who is going to get better

     

    I don't think the Sir Bobby Robson statue is very good, doesn't look like him

     

    I liked Scott Parker, thought he was a good player for us and it was a mistake selling him

    Glenn Roeder was a decent manager for us overall

    :yao:

     

    Just to add some depth to that point, the scale goes like this, with some examples

     

    Proper Shite - Dalglish, Allardyce, Souness

    Shite - Gullit

    Decent - Roeder

    Good - Hughton

    Very Good -

    Great - Keegan, SBR

  5. I think Cleverley is a good player who is going to get better

     

    I don't think the Sir Bobby Robson statue is very good, doesn't look like him

     

    I liked Scott Parker, thought he was a good player for us and it was a mistake selling him

    Glenn Roeder was a decent manager for us overall

×
×
  • Create New...