Jump to content

duo

Member
  • Posts

    9,158
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by duo

  1. 4 minutes ago, Wilson said:

     

    Maybe so but it doesn't change the fact that Brighton are still able to overtake us. 

    This just means Brighton will be more up for it against us - imo.  Most important thing is we win our own games.

  2. 1 hour ago, madras said:

    Looks to me like it hits leg and arm simultaneously. The fact that we are having the conversation means it wasn't clear and obvious.

    I think people are missing the point here - if it 'hadn't' been given as a Pen then I agree based on the VAR footage you can't give it.  However, as it was given looking at the VAR footage you can't say for certain it hits his knee.  Thereby the Ref shouldn't overrule it.  It is simple as that.  Them are the rules they should be following - 'clear and obvious' error.  I don't know how the Refs are getting such a simple concept so completely wrong.  Just look at the Man U shout - however that was the complete opposite, you can clearly see he moves his arm to the ball - Pen.  But wasn't given.

  3. 2 minutes ago, Shadow Puppets said:

    You can quite clearly see, from every angle, that his shorts move as it hits his knee.

    You cannot man :yao: - it took VAR/Ref 5 mins to try and figure it out.  Not a chance that was a clear and obvious error.

  4. 1 minute ago, lovejoy said:

    You can only see that after it’s slowed down at a certain angle tbf, which I think is the point he’s making. It isn’t a clear and obvious error.

    I've yet to see an angle where it is clear

×
×
  • Create New...