Alan Shearer

[sempuki]

I reckon:

 

1. Schmeichel

2. G. Neville

3. A Cole

4. Vieira

5. Sol Campbell

6. Rio Ferdinand

7. Beckham

8. Roy Keane

9. Shearer

10. Henry

11. Ronaldo

More like it.

[JH]

I reckon:

 

1. Schmeichel

2. G. Neville

3. A Cole

4. Vieira

5. Sol Campbell

6. Rio Ferdinand

7. Beckham

8. Roy Keane

9. Shearer

10. Henry

11. Ronaldo

 

Not enough London players.

[mozy]

 

1. Schmeichel

2. G. Neville

3. A Cole

4. Vieira

5. Terry

6. Rio Ferdinand

7. Ronaldo

8. Scholes

9. Shearer

10. Henry

11. Giggs

 

[Tooj]

Tbf I think having Bergkamp and Henry is probably the only acceptable forward line to have without Shearer in there.

 

I think Bergkamp's the most technically gifted player to have played in the Premier League and Henry is arguably the greatest player to have played in it.

[Ndegwa]

1. Taibi

2. Cygan

3. Thatcher

4. Boumsong

5. Marcelino

6. Poulsen

7. Lewis

8. Djemba-Djemba

9. Ekoku

10. Dia

11. Rebrov

[Guest firetotheworks]

Always need to have Cantona in there imo.

 

Schmeichel

 

G.Neville

Ferdinand

Terry

A.Cole

 

Ronaldo

Scholes

Vieira

 

Cantona

 

Shearer

Henry

 

Fuck the formation.

 

[David28]

1. Taibi

2. Cygan

3. Thatcher

4. Boumsong

5. Marcelino

6. Poulsen

7. Lewis

8. Djemba-Djemba

9. Ekoku

10. Dia

11. Rebrov

 

Don't agree with that.

 

Gonzales should be playmaker, while Xisco should be there as a forward.

[Ronaldo]

Peter Schmeichel

Dennis Irwin

Tony Adams

John Terry

Ashley Cole

Cristiano Ronaldo

Paul Scholes

Frank Lampard

Thierry Henry

Alan Shearer

Didier Drogba

 

Ultra attacking, but so fuck.

[HawK]

Peter Schmeichel

Dennis Irwin

Tony Adams

John Terry

Ashley Cole

Cristiano Ronaldo

Paul Scholes

Frank Lampard

Thierry Henry

Alan Shearer

Didier Drogba

 

Ultra attacking, but so f***.

 

Drogba?

[Ronaldo]

I was tempted to put Henry up front with Shearer and Laurent Robert LW but decided against it.

[Guest palnese]

Schmeichel

 

Neville

Adams

Terry

Cole

 

Scholes

Keane

 

Ronaldo

Henry

Shearer

Giggs

[Guest firetotheworks]

Surprised by the lack of Cantona like. The bloke was incredible.

[Ronaldo]

He had maybe 3 incredible seasons. As magnificent as he was at times you couldn't put him in there ahead of someone who was great for well over a decade.

[ujpest doza]

He had maybe 3 incredible seasons. As magnificent as he was at times you couldn't put him in there ahead of someone who was great for well over a decade.

Exactly.

The omission of Shearer and Keane is staggering.

 

[Fenham Mag]

Suarez would be in some teams if he played his career out in the PL.

 

Same goes for Bale.

[Tooj]

Surprised by the lack of Cantona like. The bloke was incredible.

I think he's arguably the most overrated player of the Premiership era.

 

Right place, right time and that but I think Bergkamp was a player who was at another level. Cantona has that cult of personality surrounding him though that Bergkamp doesn't.

[ujpest doza]

Surprised by the lack of Cantona like. The bloke was incredible.

I think he's arguably the most overrated player of the Premiership era.

 

Right place, right time and that but I think Bergkamp was a player who was at another level. Cantona has that cult of personality surrounding him though that Bergkamp doesn't.

Whereas Bergkamp was an utter snide sly cunt who I remember Darren Peacock enjoying one particularly feisty encounter with both digging each other off the ball while the play was at the other end of the field and the officials therefore weren't watching.

 

[Guest Howaythetoon]

Cantona may have had a brief great spell compared to others but you have to factor in just what he meant to that side and team and how important he was. He along with Schmeichael pretty much won them the league against us and he was the one man that was consistent at either creating goals, scoring them and performing in games, especially the big games. I wouldn't have him in my all-time XI though.

 

4-4-2 based on individual strengths and consistency I'd go with:

 

Schmeichel

G.Neville

Ferdinand

Campbell

A.Cole

Ronaldo

Vieira

Lampard

Giggs

Shearer

Henry

 

That side would be lethal like.

[Guest Howaythetoon]

Surprised by the lack of Cantona like. The bloke was incredible.

I think he's arguably the most overrated player of the Premiership era.

 

Right place, right time and that but I think Bergkamp was a player who was at another level. Cantona has that cult of personality surrounding him though that Bergkamp doesn't.

 

I agree with you regarding Bergkamp, he is a class above the likes of Cantona who take away the cult of personality would be on a par with Le Tissier. Bergkamp was on another level and is easily one of the all-time Premier League greats. Had he been more selfish and played further forward he would have been a 20 + a season man, he certainly had the goal scoring ability as he could finish.

 

As a partnership it's probably hard to look beyond him and Henry, they dovetailed so well. Sometimes it's not always about statistics etc. it's about the aesthetics of play and those two were fucking dynamite on the pitch, often a level above everyone else, even players equally as good such as our own Shearer, Drogba at his height, Suarez etc.

[Incognito]

Can't believe people are ignoring Scholes.

[Incognito]

Schmeichel

Neville

Adams

Campbell

Ashley Cole

Ronaldo

Vieira

Scholes

Giggs

Shearer

Henry

 

[Guest Howaythetoon]

Can't believe people are ignoring Scholes.

 

Usually he'd be in there, but I cannot look beyond Lampard who isn't as good a footballer as Scholes was but that goal scoring ability, big game mentality, consistency etc. for me makes him stand out above then,idea of Scholes and Gerrard.

[Guest firetotheworks]

I couldn't argue with Bergkamp or Lampard being in anyone's like. Both ridiculous players in their own ways. The thing for me with Cantona is that he wasn't just a brilliant player but he was inspirational and along with Schmeichel, carried Man United to the title. I doubt I'll ever truly understand Keane being in people's teams tbh, he was an outstanding leader and inspirational, but as a footballer I never rated him that highly at all. I'd have Scholes, Vieira, Lampard, and Gerrard all ahead of him.

[Incognito]

Can't believe people are ignoring Scholes.

 

Usually he'd be in there, but I cannot look beyond Lampard who isn't as good a footballer as Scholes was but that goal scoring ability, big game mentality, consistency etc. for me makes him stand out above then,idea of Scholes and Gerrard.

Not in the same class as Scholes though it's not as if Scholes hardly scored either and his all round game totally overwhelm Lampards. Scholes is easily the best Premiership midfielder.

[Incognito]

I couldn't argue with Bergkamp or Lampard being in anyone's like. Both ridiculous players in their own ways. The thing for me with Cantona is that he wasn't just a brilliant player but he was inspirational and along with Schmeichel, carried Man United to the title. I doubt I'll ever truly understand Keane being in people's teams tbh, he was an outstanding leader and inspirational, but as a footballer I never rated him that highly at all. I'd have Scholes, Vieira, Lampard, and Gerrard all ahead of him.

I certainly cannot understand those that have selected both Vieira and Keane. Keane was a very good player just in my opinion not as good as Vieira. But you'd only need one of them whoever you prefer.