ponsaelius Posted August 4, 2017 Share Posted August 4, 2017 I'm going back a few pages but I'm interested again as to why people rate the Bundesliga so highly as a league. It seems to be largely from the fact the national team is successful and that there was an all German CL final 4 years ago. I find German football a bit of a contradiction for me. It has lots of ideals that should be admired - cheap tickets, full stadiums, 51% fan ownership, focus on youth development. If I lived in Germany I think it would be fantastic to be a match-going supporter. However out of the top 5 leagues it's easily the one I watch the least from the armchair, and I would now probably not tune into anything other than maybe Bayern vs Dortmund. I find the atmospheres bizarrely sterile despite the huge attendances. It's like watching Pro-Evo crowd, full of colour and the bouncing up and down happening without any correlation to whats going on on the pitch. Then I also find that tactically every game is very similar, with teams playing largely the same style of football and the same systems. Add to this the clubs that have competed at the top in recent years are often plastic, corporate style clubs - Leverkusen, Wolfsburg, Leipzig, Hoffenheim. Despite the good ideals, it always comes across very packaged, sanitized and boring. I'd struggle to list the derbies too, other than Dortmund vs Schalke. All seems like something I should enjoy, but I really struggle to do so. Find it dull tbh. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
themanupstairs Posted August 4, 2017 Share Posted August 4, 2017 Staying at Barca to succeed Messi is a joke tbh. Why would he do so? TBH, he probably can't. Messi is 30 and still killing it. When would Neymar take over? He would never take over precisely because Messi is ten times the player that petulant crybaby will ever be anyway. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
themanupstairs Posted August 4, 2017 Share Posted August 4, 2017 anyway if Qatar weren't spending it on Neymar's salary they'd be spending on funding ISIS wahhabism so it's probably for the best This is so true that it's almost not funny Really though, anyone associating with that cretinous government deserves everything that's coming to them. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Paully Posted August 4, 2017 Share Posted August 4, 2017 So it's a free transfer then! Neymar had to buy himself out of his contract with Barcelona in order to complete his move to France following a battle between the French and Spanish leagues over the payment of his world-record fee. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
mrmojorisin75 Posted August 4, 2017 Share Posted August 4, 2017 has the 2022 WC been mentioned at all in this? i wonder if part of the whole thing will be neymar promoting it for the qataris and such as part of an inevitable PR offensive for their shitty, tawdry WC Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Flip Posted August 4, 2017 Share Posted August 4, 2017 Does anyone actually care? Player moves to new club for lots of.money. meh. Yeah - I do. I love football but the money in the game is ruining the sport. People want to see the best players stay in the best leagues. In France it's not like the Premiership where all the clubs are benefiting from an insane TV deal, thereby all getting stronger. You have just one team that is being backed up by Sovereign Wealth which no one can compete with. Ibrahimović had more of an impact on footballing world playing the one season in England than he did in all the four seasons in France. People all over the world stood up and remembered how great a player he was. Absolutely not true regarding Ibra. Suggesting people remembered how great of a player he was only after having joined Manchester United is ridiculous. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Flip Posted August 4, 2017 Share Posted August 4, 2017 Staying at Barca to succeed Messi is a joke tbh. Why would he do so? TBH, he probably can't. Messi is 30 and still killing it. When would Neymar take over? He would never take over precisely because Messi is ten times the player that petulant crybaby will ever be anyway. No one is every going to take over from Messi unless he dies. Man is an alien. Exactly, why Neymar's move makes sense. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest palnese Posted August 4, 2017 Share Posted August 4, 2017 Neymar is a greedy little whore. The end. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
STM Posted August 4, 2017 Share Posted August 4, 2017 Staying at Barca to succeed Messi is a joke tbh. Why would he do so? TBH, he probably can't. Messi is 30 and still killing it. When would Neymar take over? He would never take over precisely because Messi is ten times the player that petulant crybaby will ever be anyway. No one is every going to take over from Messi unless he dies. Man is an alien. Exactly, why Neymar's move makes sense. In order to enhance his legacy and standing as an all time footballer, hes joining a club where he's going to play a handful of meaningful games a season? Not having that like. If he was joining Madrid or Man City/Utd perhaps. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Flip Posted August 4, 2017 Share Posted August 4, 2017 Staying at Barca to succeed Messi is a joke tbh. Why would he do so? TBH, he probably can't. Messi is 30 and still killing it. When would Neymar take over? He would never take over precisely because Messi is ten times the player that petulant crybaby will ever be anyway. No one is every going to take over from Messi unless he dies. Man is an alien. Exactly, why Neymar's move makes sense. In order to enhance his legacy and standing as an all time footballer, hes joining a club where he's going to play a handful of meaningful games a season? Not having that like. If he was joining Madrid or Man City/Utd perhaps. Sorry, but in the end in European football now, only winning the PL means something other than the Champions League. So yes, in order to enhance his legacy he wants to win the CL with PSG. Also, winning either the CL with PSG or the World Cup is going to make him the best in the world, so he has basically 'doubled' his chance of winning it. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest firetotheworks Posted August 4, 2017 Share Posted August 4, 2017 You're allowed to be objective instead of just defending things because they're Brazilian you know? Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
STM Posted August 4, 2017 Share Posted August 4, 2017 Staying at Barca to succeed Messi is a joke tbh. Why would he do so? TBH, he probably can't. Messi is 30 and still killing it. When would Neymar take over? He would never take over precisely because Messi is ten times the player that petulant crybaby will ever be anyway. No one is every going to take over from Messi unless he dies. Man is an alien. Exactly, why Neymar's move makes sense. In order to enhance his legacy and standing as an all time footballer, hes joining a club where he's going to play a handful of meaningful games a season? Not having that like. If he was joining Madrid or Man City/Utd perhaps. Sorry, but in the end in European football now, only winning the PL means something other than the Champions League. So yes, in order to enhance his legacy he wants to win the CL with PSG. Also, winning either the CL with PSG or the World Cup is going to make him the best in the world, so he has basically 'doubled' his chance of winning it. Winning the world cup or champions league isn't going to make him better than Messi. People will forget about Neymar now because we won't hear his name for weeks on end because there's no champions league football on. He's made a shocking decision, footballing wise, there's no two ways about it. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
triggs Posted August 4, 2017 Share Posted August 4, 2017 I'm going back a few pages but I'm interested again as to why people rate the Bundesliga so highly as a league. It seems to be largely from the fact the national team is successful and that there was an all German CL final 4 years ago. I find German football a bit of a contradiction for me. It has lots of ideals that should be admired - cheap tickets, full stadiums, 51% fan ownership, focus on youth development. If I lived in Germany I think it would be fantastic to be a match-going supporter. However out of the top 5 leagues it's easily the one I watch the least from the armchair, and I would now probably not tune into anything other than maybe Bayern vs Dortmund. I find the atmospheres bizarrely sterile despite the huge attendances. It's like watching Pro-Evo crowd, full of colour and the bouncing up and down happening without any correlation to whats going on on the pitch. Then I also find that tactically every game is very similar, with teams playing largely the same style of football and the same systems. Add to this the clubs that have competed at the top in recent years are often plastic, corporate style clubs - Leverkusen, Wolfsburg, Leipzig, Hoffenheim. Despite the good ideals, it always comes across very packaged, sanitized and boring. I'd struggle to list the derbies too, other than Dortmund vs Schalke. All seems like something I should enjoy, but I really struggle to do so. Find it dull tbh. Bang on. The thing about the constant noise is something I mentioned before as well. I much prefer to hear the crowd reacting to things that happen on the pitch Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Village Idiot Posted August 4, 2017 Share Posted August 4, 2017 I don't rate the Bundesliga at all either. Much, much rather watch Italian football. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Nobody Posted August 4, 2017 Share Posted August 4, 2017 Staying at Barca to succeed Messi is a joke tbh. Why would he do so? TBH, he probably can't. Messi is 30 and still killing it. When would Neymar take over? He would never take over precisely because Messi is ten times the player that petulant crybaby will ever be anyway. No one is every going to take over from Messi unless he dies. Man is an alien. Exactly, why Neymar's move makes sense. In order to enhance his legacy and standing as an all time footballer, hes joining a club where he's going to play a handful of meaningful games a season? Not having that like. If he was joining Madrid or Man City/Utd perhaps. Sorry, but in the end in European football now, only winning the PL means something other than the Champions League. So yes, in order to enhance his legacy he wants to win the CL with PSG. Also, winning either the CL with PSG or the World Cup is going to make him the best in the world, so he has basically 'doubled' his chance of winning it. What? Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Flip Posted August 4, 2017 Share Posted August 4, 2017 Staying at Barca to succeed Messi is a joke tbh. Why would he do so? TBH, he probably can't. Messi is 30 and still killing it. When would Neymar take over? He would never take over precisely because Messi is ten times the player that petulant crybaby will ever be anyway. No one is every going to take over from Messi unless he dies. Man is an alien. Exactly, why Neymar's move makes sense. In order to enhance his legacy and standing as an all time footballer, hes joining a club where he's going to play a handful of meaningful games a season? Not having that like. If he was joining Madrid or Man City/Utd perhaps. Sorry, but in the end in European football now, only winning the PL means something other than the Champions League. So yes, in order to enhance his legacy he wants to win the CL with PSG. Also, winning either the CL with PSG or the World Cup is going to make him the best in the world, so he has basically 'doubled' his chance of winning it. Winning the world cup or champions league isn't going to make him better than Messi. People will forget about Neymar now because we won't hear his name for weeks on end because there's no champions league football on. He's made a shocking decision, footballing wise, there's no two ways about it. It definitely won't, but individual prizes aren't given to the best player in the world, but to the one who has had the best individual season. Also, same way everyone forgot about Ibra? You're allowed to be objective instead of just defending things because they're Brazilian you know? Am I the only one defending him? I just see both sides of the argument, something some are either unable to or don't want to because they dislike the player. I understand the idea of this being a step down, it's a huge risk footballing wise being taken by him in moving to PSG. But people are suggesting he should've moved to Man United or City as if they actually made an offer or had the money to pay his release clause. The whole transfer is shambles, and sets quite a dangerous precedent for future transfers with the way it was paid for, but it really doesn't take away the fact (at least IMO, you can have yours) that it might be end up being a very good move for him. He's playing in a squad full of stars such as Cavani, Dani Alves, Di Maria, Verratti and isn't exactly moving to China or the Moon. The French League is like many have pointed out not great, and winning it or the French Cup won't do shit for his legacy or whatever, but surely winning the CL with PSG would be an incredible achievement right? Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Flip Posted August 4, 2017 Share Posted August 4, 2017 Staying at Barca to succeed Messi is a joke tbh. Why would he do so? TBH, he probably can't. Messi is 30 and still killing it. When would Neymar take over? He would never take over precisely because Messi is ten times the player that petulant crybaby will ever be anyway. No one is every going to take over from Messi unless he dies. Man is an alien. Exactly, why Neymar's move makes sense. In order to enhance his legacy and standing as an all time footballer, hes joining a club where he's going to play a handful of meaningful games a season? Not having that like. If he was joining Madrid or Man City/Utd perhaps. Sorry, but in the end in European football now, only winning the PL means something other than the Champions League. So yes, in order to enhance his legacy he wants to win the CL with PSG. Also, winning either the CL with PSG or the World Cup is going to make him the best in the world, so he has basically 'doubled' his chance of winning it. What? In terms of individual prizes. Not talking about being the best player on the earth, should've made that clearer. Messi is the best player, but yet CRonaldo has won those titles multiple times. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Dinho lad Posted August 4, 2017 Share Posted August 4, 2017 Neymar is on £782,000 per week at PSG. NOT ABOUT THE MONEY A football career is pretty short to be fair. Fuck off, for goodness sake. Can't believe you swallow that crap. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Flip Posted August 4, 2017 Share Posted August 4, 2017 Neymar is on £782,000 per week at PSG. NOT ABOUT THE MONEY A football career is pretty short to be fair. f*** off, for goodness sake. Can't believe you swallow that crap. Don't think he was being serious tbf. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
themanupstairs Posted August 4, 2017 Share Posted August 4, 2017 Staying at Barca to succeed Messi is a joke tbh. Why would he do so? TBH, he probably can't. Messi is 30 and still killing it. When would Neymar take over? He would never take over precisely because Messi is ten times the player that petulant crybaby will ever be anyway. No one is every going to take over from Messi unless he dies. Man is an alien. Exactly, why Neymar's move makes sense. In order to enhance his legacy and standing as an all time footballer, hes joining a club where he's going to play a handful of meaningful games a season? Not having that like. If he was joining Madrid or Man City/Utd perhaps. Sorry, but in the end in European football now, only winning the PL means something other than the Champions League. So yes, in order to enhance his legacy he wants to win the CL with PSG. Also, winning either the CL with PSG or the World Cup is going to make him the best in the world, so he has basically 'doubled' his chance of winning it. How exactly will that make him the best in the world, when Messi (and Ronaldo) are still tearing up both La Liga and the CL? Messi hasn't won the CL in a couple of seasons now and he's still the best in the world like. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Flip Posted August 4, 2017 Share Posted August 4, 2017 Staying at Barca to succeed Messi is a joke tbh. Why would he do so? TBH, he probably can't. Messi is 30 and still killing it. When would Neymar take over? He would never take over precisely because Messi is ten times the player that petulant crybaby will ever be anyway. No one is every going to take over from Messi unless he dies. Man is an alien. Exactly, why Neymar's move makes sense. In order to enhance his legacy and standing as an all time footballer, hes joining a club where he's going to play a handful of meaningful games a season? Not having that like. If he was joining Madrid or Man City/Utd perhaps. Sorry, but in the end in European football now, only winning the PL means something other than the Champions League. So yes, in order to enhance his legacy he wants to win the CL with PSG. Also, winning either the CL with PSG or the World Cup is going to make him the best in the world, so he has basically 'doubled' his chance of winning it. How exactly will that make him the best in the world, when Messi (and Ronaldo) are still tearing up both La Liga and the CL? Messi hasn't won the CL in a couple of seasons now and he's still the best in the world like. I posted above what I meant (last page) meant in terms of winning the Ballon D'Or and not actually being the best as that is Messi and is going to be Messi for a few more years at least. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Tiresias Posted August 4, 2017 Share Posted August 4, 2017 I can understand wanting to be the centre of a team etc, but in the french league? He'll boost his stats playing in it for sure, and yes he could win the champions league with them and carry them too it, but league titles will basically be meaningless, Monaco won't win again for a while with their squad demolished and no-one else will come close. It's almost less about the money that bothers me, someone is stupid enough to offer that money of course you accept, it's what seems to be a modern streak of individuality players have now. More and more we will have fans of players who do not care about clubs. I can respect going to an outside traditional aristocracy of clubs to have a project to build up, but PSG seems just easy street. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Pata Posted August 4, 2017 Share Posted August 4, 2017 I just read that Qatar Sports Investments that owns PSG have access to almost £200 billion. What were you expecting, them to burn a third of their budget on Neymar? Umm, no. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Village Idiot Posted August 4, 2017 Share Posted August 4, 2017 Yup, it looks like our first use of the Neymar money will be buying Iñigo Martínez from Real Sociedad. I approve. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Tiresias Posted August 4, 2017 Share Posted August 4, 2017 Asked why he made the move Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts