KaKa

What's all this about blame??? I'm just saying what is the simple fact, which is that he lacks quality! Despite his greatest efforts...

Whoever told you he was immense today lied to your face. Same old Milner, appears to be working hard without getting anything done! Dribble moves that don't come off...bad touches...bad passes..... Apart from the occassional great shot or cross he is not a consistent threat despite the effort he always appears to give. Definitely shouldn't be in the first team. I would rather have someone like Benayoun in his position anyday, who will consistently produce REAL quality!

I ask again? What exactly are this man's strengths!!! Lord have mercy! A serviceable player but that is about it. Not sure if he will ever be good enough to be a mainstay in our first team Might be more of a backup player for us.

i think milner has probably been our best player overall this season but i can actually see his point and think its far from dog s***! he is inconsistent with his crossing and isnt sure sometimes whether to cross or take a man on! his biggest asset by far is his workrate. i do however think that at his age he is an excellent prospect and has plenty of time to gain experience. So he's 21 and learning his game, no need for another thread pulling him down tbh. Hardly pulling him down am I mate..... Please calm down.

Like I said OCCASSIONALLY does some good things but for you to say he is a constant threat on the wing is pushing it. His work rate is really really good, but other than that doesn't do enough for me. His corner kicks are pretty dissapointing as well.....

I think he is an okay player at most at the moment, but it appears many on here think he is a major prospect for us... Can any one of those who think so please explain why? He occasionally does good things, but the majority of the time our plays breakdown when he gets involved in them. At the moment his passing is below standard as is his crossing of the ball. His best attribute for me is his workrate which is really good, other then that I struggle to think of anything else he does consistently well..... Still dissapointed by him on the whole tbh.

How about £6 million + Bendtner & Djourou? I would have that! Even though N'Zogbia is a great prospect and all.

Roeder is right on this one I'm afraid. I can't believe people are complaining about what we did in the transfer window last summer!!! First of all there was a lot of uncertainty last summer and so it was always going to be difficult for us to get all the players we needed to. Don't forget Roeder had only been in the job a few months, and even then his position wasn't that stable due to the fact we still had to contest his appointment due to the badges issue. He hadn't had a chance to set up his staff or a scouting network or anything of the sort! To make things even more difficult a freakin' world cup was taking place and this in my opinion was a huge hinderance, as things essentially couldn't get going till the competition was over. So here we are now. He has said he has a number of players in mind, but it just so happens their clubs weren't willing to let them go in January and due to the alternatives being so much lesser he has decided to wait till the summer, which will be his first real summer transfer window! If he fails this summer then and only then do we have any reason to doubt the man. Oh yeah..... Can people stop going on about how Sibierski contradicts his transfer policy!!! Roeder said Sibierski was a player he was familiar with even during his time in the French league so Roeder knew him well. He was also a free transfer, on low wages, who was happy to take a one year deal, and who had a great attitude and was happy o be a squad player! I doubt many of the players offered to us at the end of the window would have come with these terms! Roeder's biggest test will be this summer......until then please hold your horses! On the whole he has done nothing wrong. We are in a decent, if not ideal, position in the league despite the craziness at this club over the last few seasons. I can also see clear progress in the way we play football, despite missing a lot of our quality players! Patience......

Gooch is an awesome nickname! Apparently after every tackle he addresses his victim by saying..... "Sorry homey, but you just got GOOCHED" ^-^

Fair enough but he's as small as Martins and is not particularly quick or explosive. Not a striker we should have moved for! If anyone I would have thought Carew, but both Babel and Piquionne are rated higher than him so we've done the right thing if we are waiting on those two instead.

Exactly! The one thing Roeder has consistently said is that he would rather keep our transfer dealings dead quiet! Personally, I think we have enquired about taking Piquionne on loan but only if the Babel deal falls through...... HANDS OFF WENGER!!! >

Hope he's been lying to Anal about Babel too! I have a feeling he might have been 8) obviously doesn't want Anal screwing up any of our transfer moves!

I forgot to add too..... GREAT PRICE!!!!!!

I just hope people are a bit patient. He is a raw talent but he has got great potential and is an excellent character. As both our manager and assistant manager are former defenders he will definitely fulfil that potential because he will work hard. 8)

The Times tomorrow!!! Roeder close to signing defender Gary Jacob Newcastle United are believed to have agreed to sign Oguchi Onyewu from Standard Liège. Marseilles had offered £2.1 million for the defender, who has been linked with several Barclays Premiership clubs. The 6ft 4in player, who arrived in Newcastle on Saturday, would provide Glenn Roeder, the manager, with defensive cover. They are also examining the possibility of signing Frédéric Piquionne, the 28-year-old striker, on loan from St-Etienne but the move is being hampered by the French club’s demand that the deal becomes permanent at the end of the season for a fee of £5 million.

Really? Good for him. Really has to start fulfilling some of his potential.

oh dear

Deportivo only paid 1.5million for him so we are essentially offering their money back to them, which I think is fair enough as he isn't in their first team picture anymore due to differences with their coach. Seeing as the Luque deal was such a disaster and we haggled with Depor to the death over it, I can imagine Freddy being even more difficult with this. I think this deal should still have a chance as it is very similar to what happened with the Luque deal and fortunately for us it doesn't seem as though we have too much competition. We will just have to wait and see.....

So he is going somewhere? Precisely

Trezeguet ain't going nowhere and neither is Govou who is infact not thee type pf striker we need either. Aliadiere will not be leaving Arsenal due to Van Persies injury.

Someone mentioned Piquionne the other day actually. Might be a good shout. Last I heard they were trying to swap him for Marcus Bent So they're obviously eager to move him on......

Quote: Roeder, still hopeful of adding another striker to his squad before next week's transfer deadline, is weighing up a loan move for an unnamed French forward. The United boss is also keen to sign a defender and this weekend will attempt a breakthrough. Who would you like to see coming in that is either French or from the French league? Let's keep this realistic please...... ^-^

He's only 22 to be fair (like Martins). So his inconsistencty could be down to his youth and his lack of opportunities in the first team (like Martins too!) Would be good to loan if possible I think. Anyone have Roeder's number? God knows the man needs some help! >

Has anyone seen him play? A friend of mine in France thinks he is a good young striker who Glenn should be considering and we could possibly get him on loan as Bordeaux have just signed Cavenaghi. Does anyone have any views on Chamakh or seen much of him? http://www.channel4.com/sport/french_football/focus/chamakh.html

Most unbelievable thing ever!!!!!!!!! Les Reed was a joke. Can't imagine he will ever get another job. He was so confident too! Serves him right if it is indeed true he had a lot to do with Dowie getting sacked. What goes around comes around.....