Match Atmosphere

[madras]

3 minutes ago, Wallsendmag said:

 

I think the vast majority of those surveyed voted in favour of safe standing so it's what the majority want.

I'm hoping one day they don't come to you and say we want your space for corporate, your moving and people don't call you a spiteful cunt for feeling pissed off about it 

[Kid Icarus]

Didn't the same survey show that despite the majority wanting it, most wouldn't want to personally move as well?

[Wallsendmag]

5 minutes ago, madras said:

I'm hoping one day they don't come to you and say we want your space for corporate, your moving and people don't call you a spiteful cunt for feeling pissed off about it 

 

It would hardly be a new thing. They threw 1000s out of their seats in the Milburn Stand to make room for the Platinum Club. People are under the misinterpretation that bit of plastic is their own personal property but it isn't. It remains the property of the club and all they are doing is renting it off them on a seasonal basis.

Ultimately safe standing is something that would benefit the team as it would allow for a far better atmosphere and greater support for the players. If it affects you the club will will work with you to find the beat possible replacement seat I'm sure.

 

It's already happened at plenty of other clubs with minimal fuss (Chelsea converted over 25% of their stadium into safe standing), but lots of NUFC fans love a whinge!

[christ]

10 minutes ago, Kid Icarus said:

Didn't the same survey show that despite the majority wanting it, most wouldn't want to personally move as well?

Sums up our fanbase to a tee tbf.

[madras]

11 minutes ago, Wallsendmag said:

 

It would hardly be a new thing. They threw 1000s out of their seats in the Milburn Stand to make room for the Platinum Club. People are under the misinterpretation that bit of plastic is their own personal property but it isn't. It remains the property of the club and all they are doing is renting it off them on a seasonal basis.

Ultimately safe standing is something that would benefit the team as it would allow for a far better atmosphere and greater support for the players. If it affects you the club will will work with you to find the beat possible replacement seat I'm sure.

 

It's already happened at plenty of other clubs with minimal fuss (Chelsea converted over 25% of their stadium into safe standing), but lots of NUFC fans love a whinge!

And are they spiteful cunts for being pissed off about it ?

[TheBrownBottle]

28 minutes ago, Kid Icarus said:

Didn't the same survey show that despite the majority wanting it, most wouldn't want to personally move as well?

Yep, and that's the nature of society generally - they'll say 'yes' if they think it sounds like a good thing, but any follow-up question whereby it is implied that there may be a sacrifice on their behalf and suddenly there is a 'no'.

 

One for the politics threads, but this is what happens in general polling too.  'Do you think that the utilities and railways should be nationalised?' 'YES' says the majority.  'Are you willing to pay extra taxation for this?'  'NO CHANCE' is usually the reply of a significant number.  And that is the only time I'll compare the seating / standing question to why Labour lose elections despite their policies all being popular.

[TheBrownBottle]

1 hour ago, Wallsendmag said:

 

The thing is it hasn't always been the same has it? Younger more excitable people would start off in the Leazes or the Gallowgate. Then as they grew a bit older they'd migrate to the Paddocks or the "old man's corner" (Gallowgate M section) and then when/if they'd finally had enough of standing they'd move to either the West/Milburn Stand or the East Stand.

 

Now you've got the same people occupying the same seat they've had in the Gallowgate for best part of 30 years and like it or not that is the biggest problem with the atmosphere these days. Once upon a time they'd be long gone to either the East or Milburn Stand but they are still there diluting the atmosphere in what should be the loudest part of the ground.

 

The middle tier of the Gallowgate especially, which is what most people would consider gives the best view from that Stand is full of people in their 50s/60s/70s. It's never going to make for a good atmosphere. Once upon a time they would have long since moved out and those places would be occupied by teenagers/lads in their 20s/30s.

Yep - it is easily forgotten that this was pretty much what happened for a century until SJP went all-seater in the mid-90s.  You could almost trace out the seven ages of man inside the ground (not infancy of course) - all represented by different locations.  

[Wandy]

 

I haven't watched the 5-0 for a long, long time so as a warm up for today I thought I'd give the whole match a watch to see if I am just looking back at the SJP atmosphere of old with rose tinted glasses. Well, this confirmed that I'm not. A wall of noise from all four sides of the ground throughout the match.

 

Yeah, the scoreline played a part, but, even in the 15 minutes before we scored the first goal, there is a hostile intensity to the atmosphere that just is not there anymore at SJP. 

 

Watching this really made me miss the days of the pre-Level 7 St James's. If the ground is extended they really need to take stadium accoustics into consideration to keep the noise inside the ground.

[TheBrownBottle]

3 minutes ago, Wandy said:

 

I haven't watched the 5-0 for a long, long time so as a warm up for today I thought I'd give the whole match a watch to see if I am just looking back at the SJP atmosphere of old with rose tinted glasses. Well, this confirmed that I'm not. A wall of noise from all four sides of the ground throughout the match.

 

Yeah, the scoreline played a part, but, even in the 15 minutes before we scored the first goal, there is a hostile intensity to the atmosphere that just is not there anymore at SJP. 

 

Watching this really made me miss the days of the pre-Level 7 St James's. If the ground is extended they really need to take stadium accoustics into consideration to keep the noise inside the ground.

The fixture and the opposition made the atmosphere that night - there were plenty of turgid atmospheres that season.  Half the articles in The Mag in the mid-90s were whinges about the shite atmosphere from the all-seater stadium (and the grumbling about 'glory seekers' who'd came into the ground).   The home game vs Sheff Wed earlier in the season I recollect being about as flat as it could be for a capacity crowd.

[geordiesteve710]

On 30/03/2023 at 13:44, Hovagod said:

Man Utd fans were completely silent at SJP last year and our crowd was excellent. This love in with Man Utd's away support is such a weird offshoot of their lavish success in the 90s. When have they ever demonstrated defiance in the face of their more recent set of circumstances? They fucked off like Sunderland fans during their hammerings at both City and Liverpool. When did you last see a half empty away end of ours way before full time?

 

The wankathon over Man Utd fans in this thread is really bizarre like. I've been to Old Trafford shit loads of times to watch Newcastle and the atmosphere is never like the YouTube video linked above. Could just as easily post a link of the Arsenal game at SJP last year and claim there's no problem at our stadium, which we'd all know is bollocks.

 

They will be loud today because their away fans always are (unless they go home at halftime) but even at Wembley they didn't come over particularly loud either (although the stadium acoustics might not have helped admittedly) and they were streaming out in their thousands before the cup had even been lifted.

 

Such a bizarre fanbase to romanticise.

 

 

As for our fans today, I don't know what to expect. If people realise how big a game it is we should be up for it from the off, but Sunday games are odd and I think it will depend on what happens on the pitch which is a shame. One of the loudest games I've ever seen at SJP was 97/98 (I think) when Cole scored the only goal and celebrated by dancing all the way down the East Stand touchline. Even though Newcastle were dogshit that day and didn't make a proper chance until injury time, the atmosphere was 90 minutes of intimidating noise. Could do with that today really.

[geordiesteve710]

12 hours ago, TheGuv said:

Watch what happens at half time tomorrow. Everyone sitting will stand for 15 minutes. But they won’t do it during the game.

 

It’s bizarre. 

While we're on the subject of halftime the first 5 minutes of the second half is an embarrassment and has been for as long as I can remember.

 

Like people think there's a warmup before the second half begins or something.

[Wandy]

1 minute ago, TheBrownBottle said:

The fixture and the opposition made the atmosphere that night - there were plenty of turgid atmospheres that season.  Half the articles in The Mag in the mid-90s were whinges about the shite atmosphere from the all-seater stadium (and the grumbling about 'glory seekers' who'd came into the ground).   The home game vs Sheff Wed earlier in the season I recollect being about as flat as it could be for a capacity crowd.

 

True. The difference though is that, even on one of the better days, the modern-day SJP atmosphere never hits the heights of old.

[TheBrownBottle]

3 minutes ago, geordiesteve710 said:

 

The wankathon over Man Utd fans in this thread is really bizarre like. I've been to Old Trafford shit loads of times to watch Newcastle and the atmosphere is never like the YouTube video linked above. Could just as easily post a link of the Arsenal game at SJP last year and claim there's no problem at our stadium, which we'd all know is bollocks.

 

They will be loud today because their away fans always are (unless they go home at halftime) but even at Wembley they didn't come over particularly loud either (although the stadium acoustics might not have helped admittedly) and they were streaming out in their thousands before the cup had even been lifted.

 

Such a bizarre fanbase to romanticise.

 

 

As for our fans today, I don't know what to expect. If people realise how big a game it is we should be up for it from the off, but Sunday games are odd and I think it will depend on what happens on the pitch which is a shame. One of the loudest games I've ever seen at SJP was 97/98 (I think) when Cole scored the only goal and celebrated by dancing all the way down the East Stand touchline. Even though Newcastle were dogshit that day and didn't make a proper chance until injury time, the atmosphere was 90 minutes of intimidating noise. Could do with that today really.

Yeah, I remember that match - it was a bear pit for any game vs Man Utd during that period.  Cole acting the cunt didn't exactly help  - there was a bloke who sat near me who was ejected during Cole's celebrations (he was apoplectic - though 'happily' not in a racist way, just in an angry rabid-dog hating on all things Man Utd kind of way.  It was completely owa the top, nonetheless).

[Wandy]

5 minutes ago, geordiesteve710 said:

 

The wankathon over Man Utd fans in this thread is really bizarre like. I've been to Old Trafford shit loads of times to watch Newcastle and the atmosphere is never like the YouTube video linked above. Could just as easily post a link of the Arsenal game at SJP last year and claim there's no problem at our stadium, which we'd all know is bollocks.

 

They will be loud today because their away fans always are (unless they go home at halftime) but even at Wembley they didn't come over particularly loud either (although the stadium acoustics might not have helped admittedly) and they were streaming out in their thousands before the cup had even been lifted.

 

Such a bizarre fanbase to romanticise.

 

 

As for our fans today, I don't know what to expect. If people realise how big a game it is we should be up for it from the off, but Sunday games are odd and I think it will depend on what happens on the pitch which is a shame. One of the loudest games I've ever seen at SJP was 97/98 (I think) when Cole scored the only goal and celebrated by dancing all the way down the East Stand touchline. Even though Newcastle were dogshit that day and didn't make a proper chance until injury time, the atmosphere was 90 minutes of intimidating noise. Could do with that today really.

 

Don't think anyone is romanticising them. Rather, there is embarrassment that our support has sank to something like their level at home games. But also an appreciation that their support has made an effort to turn their home atmosphere around.

 

The one area that they do excel in though is their songbook, it's head and shoulders above everyone else in the league for variety.

[madras]

7 minutes ago, Wandy said:

 

True. The difference though is that, even on one of the better days, the modern-day SJP atmosphere never hits the heights of old.

I dont know if your original link was in response to my bit about the Gallowgate, if it was I was meaning  when the Gallowgate was standing and we were regularly getting crowds round the 20,000 Mark. If it wasn't, as you were.

[Wandy]

2 minutes ago, madras said:

I dont know if your original link was in response to my bit about the Gallowgate, if it was I was meaning  when the Gallowgate was standing and we were regularly getting crowds round the 20,000 Mark. If it wasn't, as you were.

 

It wasn't. Which post of yours are you referring to?

[geordiesteve710]

32 minutes ago, Wandy said:

 

True. The difference though is that, even on one of the better days, the modern-day SJP atmosphere never hits the heights of old.

 

Yep.

 

Even the all-seater 36,500 was (or seemed to be) noisier than 52,000 after expansion.

 

I don't accept that it's just down to the stadium acoustics either.

[Wandy]

3 minutes ago, geordiesteve710 said:

 

Yep.

 

Even the all-seater 36,500 was (or seemed to be) noisier than 52,000 after expansion.

 

I don't accept that it's just down to the stadium acoustics either.

 

It definitely isn't. Just watch that 5-0 from 1996 again and watch the crowd. It was far less family-orientated. Like it or not, that made a huge difference.

 

I still love watching the radgies in the old benches jumping off their seats in reaction to match events. Cracks me up every time. 

[geordiesteve710]

5 minutes ago, Wandy said:

 

It definitely isn't. Just watch that 5-0 from 1996 again and watch the crowd. It was far less family-orientated. Like it or not, that made a huge difference.

 

I still love watching the radgies in the old benches jumping off their seats in reaction to match events. Cracks me up every time. 

Even the old family enclosure in front of the East Stand boxes gave away players as much, if not more, grief than anywhere else in the ground! 

[geordiesteve710]

Also think we lost something of a competitive advantage when the paddocks closed and then again when the media deck was installed directly behind the managers. I honestly don't think Klopp or this twat today would have the balls to leave the dugout let alone approach the fourth official! 

[Wallsendmag]

1 hour ago, madras said:

And are they spiteful cunts for being pissed off about it ?

 

They should move for the greater good (better atmosphere/better support to the team) for a similar positioned seat elsewhere inside the stadium (Gallowgate middle for Leazes middle etc) unless they are happy to be part of a standing section. As I said earlier it's not "their" seat anyway. They rent it per season from the club.

 

[Wallsendmag]

23 minutes ago, geordiesteve710 said:

Even the old family enclosure in front of the East Stand boxes gave away players as much, if not more, grief than anywhere else in the ground! 

 

We used to sit there in the very early 90s. Could get very rowdy tbf 

[bealios]

Still some life in the old dog yet.

[Holloway]

That sounded great on tv like, not a silence in evidence,never mind an eerie one 

[jack j]

Think I'm the problem tbh. 2nd one I've missed in a row and it sounded spot on again