Alan Smith (my MotM) will prove to be more important than Geremi

[Numbers]

Thought all four of the new signings were very impressive today.

 

Rozehnal was occasionally shaky tbh.

 

First game in the premiership,i wouldnt say shaky tbh id say inexperienced,was good 1st half but he dwelled on the ball a bit too much in the 2nd half.

[Guest Phil K]

A few people on here will be, to paraphrase Alan Partridge, getting a plate and a knife and fork, and eating their words about Mr. Smith methinks.

Bit early for smugness don't you think ?

That said, I freely admit I'm one who had grave doubts.

Delighted to be proved (at the minute) wrong.

[Guest Gemmill]

A few people on here will be, to paraphrase Alan Partridge, getting a plate and a knife and fork, and eating their words about Mr. Smith methinks.

Bit early for smugness don't you think ?

That said, I freely admit I'm one who had grave doubts.

Delighted to be proved (at the minute) wrong.

 

Says the king of the "I told you so" posts.

[Cajun]

I said I didn't think we needed him, great news that he done well today and I hope he keeps it up, will be more than happy to eat that humble pie.

[Guest Knightrider]

Aye it is early like, he's not a top player and never will be, but he's a cracking squad player.

[Parky]

I said I didn't think we needed him, great news that he done well today and I hope he keeps it up, will be more than happy to eat that humble pie.

 

....the art of which you have painfully learnt no doubt. 

[Cajun]

I said I didn't think we needed him, great news that he done well today and I hope he keeps it up, will be more than happy to eat that humble pie.

 

....the art of which you have painfully learnt no doubt. 

 

Edit: Speaking of humble pie http://www.newcastle-online.com/nufcforum/index.php?topic=30003.0 how does it taste then parklife? 

[tmonkey]

I said I didn't think we needed him, great news that he done well today and I hope he keeps it up, will be more than happy to eat that humble pie.

 

....the art of which you have painfully learnt no doubt. 

 

Did you notice the thread where I posted a link from last year? The one where you said something like you thought Berbatov will be a waste of money....?

 

He looked woeful against Sunderland to be fair.

 

Hope he flops. Dont know why, I suppose its because he seems to have turned into the world's best striker after a few good cup performances.

[Cajun]

I said I didn't think we needed him, great news that he done well today and I hope he keeps it up, will be more than happy to eat that humble pie.

 

....the art of which you have painfully learnt no doubt. 

 

Did you notice the thread where I posted a link from last year? The one where you said something like you thought Berbatov will be a waste of money....?

 

He looked woeful against Sunderland to be fair.

 

Hope he flops. Dont know why, I suppose its because he seems to have turned into the world's best striker after a few good cup performances.

 

Still would say a serving of humble pie is in order. Don't think there is any difference in that and me saying I don't think we need Smith.

[Parky]

I said I didn't think we needed him, great news that he done well today and I hope he keeps it up, will be more than happy to eat that humble pie.

 

....the art of which you have painfully learnt no doubt. 

 

Did you notice the thread where I posted a link from last year? The one where you said something like you thought Berbatov will be a waste of money....?

 

He looked woeful against Sunderland to be fair.

 

Hope he flops. Dont know why, I suppose its because he seems to have turned into the world's best striker after a few good cup performances.

 

Still would say a serving of humble pie is in order. Don't think there is any difference in that and me saying I don't think we need Smith.

 

 

You plainly were of the opinion we 'didn't need' Smith....Even thought you knew Barton was out for 2 months and Owen was injured and we'd lose Geremi for 8 weeks early in the new year. You have admitted already you realise you were wrong which is the sign of a gentleman.

[dcmk]

geremi is the pirlo of our team.  but being more rounded in fact he can defend.

 

alan smith has the gattusso spirit, and can attack fairly well.

 

ask me we have a better team than AC Milan :D

[Baggio]

I've just watched the first half on Sky and Martins, Viduka, Geremi, Milner and N'Zogbia have all been involved alot more than Smith who hasn't done anything of note so far.

 

I'm expecting a stunning second half from him if he's MOTM.

[Cajun]

I said I didn't think we needed him, great news that he done well today and I hope he keeps it up, will be more than happy to eat that humble pie.

 

....the art of which you have painfully learnt no doubt. 

 

Did you notice the thread where I posted a link from last year? The one where you said something like you thought Berbatov will be a waste of money....?

 

He looked woeful against Sunderland to be fair.

 

Hope he flops. Dont know why, I suppose its because he seems to have turned into the world's best striker after a few good cup performances.

 

Still would say a serving of humble pie is in order. Don't think there is any difference in that and me saying I don't think we need Smith.

 

 

You plainly were of the opinion we 'didn't need' Smith....Even thought you knew Barton was out for 2 months and Owen was injured and we'd lose Geremi for 8 weeks early in the new year. You have admitted already you realise you were wrong which is the sign of a gentleman.

 

Early days, Smith has exactly the type of mentality I like in a player but I am still unsure whether or not the £6m could have been spent better elsewhere. That said I will definitely support him as a player and you wont see me getting on his back.

[Guest]

Still gives away free-kicks for fun, and doesn't create enough. He is a grafter though. Whether that's enough to be a success, time will tell.

[Guest jamesmartinsmith]

I wasn't too impressed with Viduka. Smith and Butt however were superb, Geremi looked a bit shaky.

[tmonkey]

I've just watched the first half on Sky and Martins, Viduka, Geremi, Milner and N'Zogbia have all been involved alot more than Smith who hasn't done anything of note so far.

 

I'm expecting a stunning second half from him if he's MOTM.

 

Hes been very average, barely noticeable. But hes MOTM because hes Alan Smith and he works hard.

 

Decent/good signing for games like this in all honesty, ie the Evertons, Boltons and Blackburns. Hes solid and a good option for central midfield if we want solidity, something which i admit to have overlooked in the rage at the price.

 

Not as good a player as Geremi though.

[tmonkey]

I wasn't too impressed with Viduka. Smith and Butt however were superb, Geremi looked a bit shaky.

 

Geremi has been the most composed player on the park in my eyes.

[Superior Acuña]

Thought all four of the new signings were very impressive today.

 

Rozehnal was occasionally shaky tbh.

 

?

 

i thought he was one of our best players.

[Syrette]

Thought all four of the new signings were very impressive today.

 

Rozehnal was occasionally shaky tbh.

 

?

 

i thought he was one of our best players.

 

So do I, he was still a bit shaky though once or twice. Don't hold it against him in the slightest though, 1st game etc etc. For "shaky" read: "inexperienced". He's liable to make a few mistakes because of this.

[Baggio]

Thought all four of the new signings were very impressive today.

 

Rozehnal was occasionally shaky tbh.

 

?

 

i thought he was one of our best players.

 

So do I, he was still a bit shaky though. Don't hold it against him in the slightest though, 1st game etc etc.

 

I think (or hope) it's just him getting used to the pace of the Premiership, he's finding out he can't keep possession as long as he did in the French league.

[Syrette]

Thought all four of the new signings were very impressive today.

 

Rozehnal was occasionally shaky tbh.

 

?

 

i thought he was one of our best players.

 

So do I, he was still a bit shaky though. Don't hold it against him in the slightest though, 1st game etc etc.

 

I think (or hope) it's just him getting used to the pace of the Premiership, he's finding out he can't keep possession as long as he did in the French league.

 

Yeah, I'd go along with that.  Once or twice he seemed to want to take us forward and hold onto it instead of taking a more simple but defensively secure option. I'm hopeful that he'll be able to really adapt because (albeit based on a few friendlies and one meaningful game) he looks like he's got a lot of attributes as a CD and will partner up well with Taylor.

[Liam Liam Liam O]

I've just watched the first half on Sky and Martins, Viduka, Geremi, Milner and N'Zogbia have all been involved alot more than Smith who hasn't done anything of note so far.

 

I'm expecting a stunning second half from him if he's MOTM.

 

and thats the difference between watching it on the TV and being there, because Smith was excellent today, particularly defensively

[Baggio]

I've just watched the first half on Sky and Martins, Viduka, Geremi, Milner and N'Zogbia have all been involved alot more than Smith who hasn't done anything of note so far.

 

I'm expecting a stunning second half from him if he's MOTM.

 

and thats the difference between watching it on the TV and being there, because Smith was excellent today, particularly defensively

 

Except the lad who started this thread based his opinion of Smith being MotM from watching it through an Internet stream, which would have been the same footage I'm watching.

[Liam Liam Liam O]

I've just watched the first half on Sky and Martins, Viduka, Geremi, Milner and N'Zogbia have all been involved alot more than Smith who hasn't done anything of note so far.

 

I'm expecting a stunning second half from him if he's MOTM.

 

and thats the difference between watching it on the TV and being there, because Smith was excellent today, particularly defensively

 

Except the lad who started this thread based his opinion of Smith being MotM from watching it through an Internet stream, which would have been the same footage I'm watching.

 

Yes but your assertion was that Smith would have to excellent in the second half because he was poor in the first, doing nothing of note.  In fact he did loads in an excellent first and was also pretty good in the second as well.

[tmonkey]

I've just watched the first half on Sky and Martins, Viduka, Geremi, Milner and N'Zogbia have all been involved alot more than Smith who hasn't done anything of note so far.

 

I'm expecting a stunning second half from him if he's MOTM.

 

and thats the difference between watching it on the TV and being there, because Smith was excellent today, particularly defensively

 

In your opinion