Scottish Mag
-
Posts
1,010 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Posts posted by Scottish Mag
-
-
Gianfranco Zola as his assistant btw...
-
I thought this was in reference to the Old Firm thread being bumped yesterday
-
ONut I know you like your French Football. How defensive a team was Houlliers Lyon side?
-
To be fair whilst I know generally people are saying you shouldn't return to a club but its not doing Rangers any harm having Wattie Smith back. After having been a shambles for a couple of years they are currently above Celtic in the league.
-
KK is a better manager than Redknapp.
Are you sure? his record at England and Citeh is s****. Maybe he was lucky as SJP?
Redknapps first spell at Pompey is the only time he has had a better win percentage than Kevin Keegans "s****" Manchester City
Kevin Keegan
Man City - Win percentage - 43.75%
Harry Redknapp
West Ham - Win percentage - 37.00%
Portsmouth - Win percentage - 46.55%
Southamption - Win percentage - 26.53%
Portsmouth - Win percentage - 40.48%
-
but Celtic fans feel the need to tell everyone what a club they are, with massive signings like, Mark Wilson and Scott McDonald, because clearly they're insecure about how they are perceived.
Nottrophysigningtastic
Scott McDonald is the SPLs top scorer and Wilson was regarded as one the best young full backs in the country when he signed and after what looked like a good start to his career at Celtic picked up a few injuries and had yet to show the same form that earned him a move to Celtic. I certainly had him down as a potential full back for the national team before his loss of form.
Both the Old Firm have had many "trophy signings" that have failed, what does it matter where they came from or how much they cost if they are effective signings.
-
-
I doubt Hughes will come here, Man U will be his next job after Blackburn, nothing is certain but it looks likely.
A few years ago everyone was saying the same about MON. Do you honestly think the Glazers will employ him rather than a proven top class winner.
-
From the BBC
A chant of "Hughsie, Hughsie" goes up from the Blackburn fans. "Please don't go to Newcastle," they whisper under their breath.
It will be him in my honest opinion
Agreed
-
What part of "Hitzfeld is only interested in the Swiss job" do people not understand?
Any of it by the looks of it, at least we're looking at better options which is just as important.
Are we though or is it just paper talk?
-
Not saying he's the man to save us but Keegan had retired from football the last time we got him. He was living in Spain playing golf. He wasn't involved in football. If nothing else the guy could motivate.
Yep just look at this inspirational video...
-
yes i can confirm you've just had a text saying keegan was at St James's now.Just had a text saying Keegan is at St James's now - anyone confirm?
Source?
You.
-
He was talking sense though at times, he did actually say our fans have realised attacking football isn't all the be all and end all, and that results come first and football after that.
Aye I agree. I thought he came across pretty well.
-
were holding the Shearer banner today?
Clueless f****** twats.
They lifted the wrong one, they had left their Hitzfeld one at home...
-
im worried they are going to get us back for the 5-0 here...
They do that nearly every fucking season
-
(1) Alan Shearers Character. He is a strong character, just look at his on-pitch behaviours, attitude, leadership, during his time with us and England. Just remember (as one simple example) how he faced down the tough-nut Keane and made him look and behave like a weak-minded idiot.
Whilst no one can question Shearers on passion and commitment on the park I do not think he was a great leader in the slightest. IMO he wasnt a great captain or communicator, with Speed often taking on the role of unofficial captain.
-
I understand that there are many different views on this. It is both the strength (and weakness) of all these internet forums and 24/7 Sky-Sports-News coverage, that so many different views (with their opportunity to influence your thinking) are imposed on us, causing confusion among what is probably an amazingly simple situation.
ALAN SHEARER IS THE MAN TO LEAD NEWCASTLE UNITED FC FOR THE NEXT 20 YEARS.
Top post
Who else could you EVER say that about?
Seriously?
Any other choice from amongst the available managers would not ever do that - would they?
Whether they were "European Cup winning" top foreign managers, or the (so-called) "cream of English managers" they would only be here short term, would be mercenaries (obviously, that's the way it is) and (in all probability, despite their pedigree and great CV) they would probably FAIL.
Alan Shearer is not just a "former great player" . . that is the reason so many people give when arguing against him. They say - "a great player does not necessarily make a great manager". VERY VERY TRUE!! A good painter and decorator does not necessarily make a good accountant. Yes, we all know that. That is obvious.
However, with Shearer, that ignores the many things that make up Alan Shearer that do not fit with that (very) simple statement (no matter how many times it is repeated) that DO uniquely apply to the (VERY unique) combination of - "Alan Shearer and Newcastle United" . . .
FIVE REASONS:
(1) Alan Shearers Character. He is a strong character, just look at his on-pitch behaviours, attitude, leadership, during his time with us and England. Just remember (as one simple example) how he faced down the tough-nut Keane and made him look and behave like a weak-minded idiot.
(2) Alan Shearers respect around the world, as a 'recent' top world player. How good that would be in attracting players of the TOP quality. (players that the likes of Allardyce and Redknapp and so many others, would never even get to speak to).
(3) Alan Shearers love of Newcastle United FC. It seems to me, when listening to him, that his feelings for the club are just like mine. They are just like yours too!! He cares, just like we do - unconditionally and forever. Unlike you and me though - he is in a position to do something about it!
(4) Alan Shearer lives here because he wants to. Even the parochial, automatically biased Southern English press (aided by the riduculous Oliver guy) would not even be tempted to say - "Alan, what about the weather and the shops, would your wife not prefer to live in Basingtoke or Bogner???"
(5) Alan Shearer seems to have all the abilities needed to be very good at what the job requires (particulary, at THIS club) uniquely perhaps, amongst the many football players that have retired in recent times. Those are rare qualities in any walk of life, that make him different.
FINALLY:
It is so true that "a great player does not necessarily make a great manager". BUT, when it appears that there is one who would - and it is almost specifically ONLY at OUR club - then we should . . . . GO FOR IT !!!!!!!!!!
In my opinion . . .
Top post
Seconded
A lot of people on here are saying no to Shearer because of his inexperience. I personally think this could be his advantage. He will be far more open to changing his ideas if he has to as he will not have a tried and tested formula.
People forget that he got us into europe a couple of seasons ago. I know, that was Roeder, but if you are honestly telling me that it wasn't Shearers influence as no.2 and it was Roeders leadership skills i think i might find you funnier than Joey Bartons headdoctors namesake.
The money and prestige that Shearer will bring in will make Ashley far more likely to open his wallet, and i honestly think Big Al will have a good eye for talent.
Remember Keegan came with no experience, he lifted the place with his aura which the players fed off, and it will be the same for Shearer. Every player will be that 20% better than they have ever been.
I am a realist and believe we have no chance of appointing Mourinho, so give Shearer the chance
People want to believe that it was Shearer but its much more likely that Tommy Craig was the key man in the set up. Was that not the reason he was pissed off and left when they tried to demote him back to the reserves...
-
-
Was tongue in cheek mate. I am gobsmacked by the number of people who would be happy with Shearer in charge. I find it astonishing that the forums have been full of people whining and bitching all day about not getting the likes of Mourinho and Lippi to getting excited about someone with no experience of coaching (with the exception of standing in a dug out on match days in Roeders run) and managing.
If it was any other person with no coaching or managerial experience Tyneside would be up in arms but no its "Sheeeeeeeera!!!" so somehow its acceptable....
You being a jock mag should know about the impact some rookie managers can make:
Kenny D @ Liverpool
Souey @ Rangers
Keegan @ Newcastle
Some being the key word there. For everyone of them there is a Stuart Pearce or John Barnes. Would you honestly be happy if it was any other "rookie" (Beardsley, Gazza, Speed) or is it just because it is "Shearer"?
*Oh and Souness was lucky to manage a big spending Rangers side when no other team in Scotland has any money nor were they any good*
-
Shearer is a Legend weshould have him with Kenny Dalglish as his assistant.
Dogleash acting as the wise old head to a young manager who's first job is gaffer at a well supported club it has been done before with devastating effect.
But what does that matter its "Sheeeeeeeeeeeeeeeera" we are talking about....
Someone mentioned Dalglish as his assistant
Was tongue in cheek mate. I am gobsmacked by the number of people who would be happy with Shearer in charge. I find it astonishing that the forums have been full of people whining and bitching all day about not getting the likes of Mourinho and Lippi to getting excited about someone with no experience of coaching (with the exception of standing in a dug out on match days in Roeders run) and managing.
If it was any other person with no coaching or managerial experience Tyneside would be up in arms but no its "Sheeeeeeeera!!!" so somehow its acceptable....
Agree with this. Because he "loves the club" has no baring on whether he'd be good for us or not. When Ferguson leaves Man Utd do you think they'd be happy with Ince (who does have a bit of experience) because "he loves the club"?
But we aren't Man Utd! Of the options realistically available I think Shearer would be the most exciting. Keegan had no managerial experience and did okay! Also, those saying he looks like a numpty on MOTD are right, but then they all do. I think there has been some kind of BBC directive to be as dull as possible after the FA started taking coverage away from them when they were perceived as too negative about England when they actually said f*** all. Even Hansen, who I used to think was incredibly knowledgeable and a great pundit, is now w***. I don't think it's because they're lazy, i think it's because they are told to be (with the exception of wright, who is a moron)
Based on what?
-
Shearer is a Legend weshould have him with Kenny Dalglish as his assistant.
Dogleash acting as the wise old head to a young manager who's first job is gaffer at a well supported club it has been done before with devastating effect.
Someone like Dalglish or Keegan working alongside Shearer and I might go along with it. The time to worry is if he brings in his cronies like Lee & Speed who also have no experience.
REMEMBER HOW GOOD A MENTOR KENNY DEE WAS TO JOHN BARNES!!!
WE MUST STAY WELL CLEAR OF KENNY OR THIS KENNY WILL KILL US, THE b******.
That was more down to the sh*teness of Barnes
Barnes was s*** but I think Kenny was meant to help him out as DOF,mentor or whatever he was & it was Kenny who took Terry Mac to Celtic ffs.
Where he done fuck all too. And the talk was that his actual role was "Social Convenor"
-
Shearer is a Legend weshould have him with Kenny Dalglish as his assistant.
Dogleash acting as the wise old head to a young manager who's first job is gaffer at a well supported club it has been done before with devastating effect.
But what does that matter its "Sheeeeeeeeeeeeeeeera" we are talking about....
Someone mentioned Dalglish as his assistant
Was tongue in cheek mate. I am gobsmacked by the number of people who would be happy with Shearer in charge. I find it astonishing that the forums have been full of people whining and bitching all day about not getting the likes of Mourinho and Lippi to getting excited about someone with no experience of coaching (with the exception of standing in a dug out on match days in Roeders run) and managing.
If it was any other person with no coaching or managerial experience Tyneside would be up in arms but no its "Sheeeeeeeera!!!" so somehow its acceptable....
-
Shearer is a Legend weshould have him with Kenny Dalglish as his assistant.
Dogleash acting as the wise old head to a young manager who's first job is gaffer at a well supported club it has been done before with devastating effect.
But what does that matter its "Sheeeeeeeeeeeeeeeera" we are talking about....
-
Shearer would be really interesting, he would be the first manager since Bobby that fully understands the club and the fans, before Bobby was Keegan, it could work.
sod understanding the fans. I want a winner!
Deschamps jumps from 80/1 to favourite with bookmakers
in Football
Posted
There is no way he got those odds. You get shorter odds on the likes of Ant and Dec...