That's your problem though, isn't it? You always seem to rate players with those attributes above the players of the attributes of the likes of Shearer, Batistuta, etc. You seem to prefer the likes of Bergkamps, Zolas, etc over the likes of Shearer's, etc...... it's just your personal choice, it doesn't necessarily mean that a player with flair is better than a "workman like" player.
I even remember you once claiming that Batistuta and Shearer never troubled defenders in the same way as Bergkamp, Zola, Ronaldinho, etc. (Some long post your wrote about this subject years back.) Completely not true, imo.