Teasy

from danwalkerbbc So why was a £35m bid rejected then.. It wasnt. They released that we rejected their 2nd offer & gave no details on what that was, we may well have accepted a 3rd by that point & been calming a backlash. Its common sense. Common sense?, really? Its common sense to say that we hadn't rejected a bid, because we probably, maybe, perhaps had accepted a third bid, so Carroll then asked to leave instead of just leaving and picking up his part of the transfer? That's common sense now?

So now its SSN fault for saying we'd sell for £35m, even though we then rejected that offer When is it Carroll's fault?

Yeah going on past trends is delusional. Where as pulling opinions out of your arse is sound logic. I am going on past trends. No you aren't. The whole ethos of the club is value for money. We don't sign big name players any more. If we spend this £35m it won't be on any top players like Andy Carroll. Therefore none of them will be in double figures. Fairly straight forward if you ask me. But how does that gel with: "Got to love the delusion of people thinking this money will be reinvested in the squad to a decent degree". If we spend £30m on 4 or 5 players that improve their respective positions in the team then we'll have reinvested the money to a decent degree yes? I don't see anyone here believing we're going to go and spend £35m on one player..

Yeah going on past trends is delusional. Where as pulling opinions out of your arse is sound logic. I am going on past trends. No you aren't.

Its incredible that this scenario, which is you're opinion not fact, leaves Carroll completely blameless.

Yeah going on past trends is delusional. Where as pulling opinions out of your arse is sound logic.

Wrong

10 mp paid over 10 years, 10 mp after starting 100 times for Liverpool , 10 mp after 50 England caps and the last 5 mp after 100 England caps. Its £35m plus addons, not £35m of addons

To be fair, even if true why would he want to do that? He'd be effectively telling his new employers and their fans that he didn't want to go there. No he wouldn't, how many players leave and go to other clubs without handing in transfer requests? Do we assume all of them didn't want to be their? All he'd be doing is explaining that he didn't actually ask to leave.

He was showing ambition by refusing an offer that's well above what Carroll is really worth, so Carroll decides he'll leave because of lack of ambition? Its a contradiction mate, and just another way to try to defend the lad.

Did they all ask to leave?

this. Not this. They did not reject the transfer They did. How ? Before the muppet handed in his request. They didnt reject a transfer, they held out for a higher price That is you fitting things into your conspiracy theory. That is basic common sense ffs. If someone has a massive amount of money coming in & is desperate for something you own, you dont accept the first offer they give you. Dont be simple. They were silent all day & made no attempt to come out to state he wasnt for sale atall. They kept inviting offers, explain how they didnt. They rejected a transfer, Carroll clearly tapped up by Liverpool put's in transfer request forcing Ashley's hand. NUFC then accept the next bid, as they want to try to get replacement in ASAP. You are Ashley's favourite fan. He must wish every Geordie was as naive as you are. Aye, and I bet your one the people that believe ashley has made money while at NUFC. Fact is Ashley showed some ambition by signing Ben Arfa this month when he didn't have to. How much? I'll transfer £100 to the server account right away if you can find proof. If you can't, you do it. Well he bought the club for £125M. Has take on £100M worth of debt and Loans. Has put in £20M for each for the last 3 seasons. What the fuck are you on about? Are you drunk? £100 for you to find proof that I'm 'one of those people who believe that Ashley has made money at NUFC'. Yes or no? If you can't, transfer £100 into the server account. Is he drunk? You're asking if he's drunk??

What, by rejecting a record fee for him? Then accepting a bigger one, yes. They accepted the same deal, only after Carroll asked to leave. But of course Ashley used his mind control to make him put in the request. I'm honestly astounded at the stupidity of this conspiracy bullshit, and thats saying something considering this is the internet.

Aye we were struggling to resist so much that we stayed silent & kept inviting offers. Poor Ashley, hes been completely caught off guard Fucking hell We rejected the bid and he asked to leave! Get it through your fucking head! Stop making excuses for Carroll.

Keep going, this is getting better. Amazing isnt it :lol;

Some people never learn. Fantastic deal for Fat Mike yes, but not for NUFC. Your one of them.

Yeah why didn't we just handcuff him to a radiator until the window closed.. Common ffs, we did well to resist such an insane offer to begin with. He's asked to leave now, we cant do much more.

We rejected an offer to get a better price. It's called negotiating. When we got our price, we were willing to sell him, but Ashley didn't want to alienate the fans, which he would have done for the umpteenth time. So he told Carroll to stick a transfer request in, and now he can say 'look, I rejected a bid and he handed a transfer request in so I just made sure Liverpool paid good money for him'. It's PR, man. You're daft if you think this stuff doesn't happen regularly. Exactly. Oh my god!! This is delusion/stupidity beyond belief.

So Carroll agrees to make himself look the cunt because Ashley says so? How is anyone this stupid? Because he's no longer a Newcastle player. What the fuck are you talking about?? Seriously people have lost their fucking minds.

This Obviously. It couldnt be more blatant. So Carroll will be coming out and telling us that request never happened yes?

Where does a transfer request fit into your story?

Oh fucking hell not you too

So Carroll agrees to make himself look the cunt because Ashley says so? How is anyone this stupid?

Totally delusional.

i wont regret it, i get no share of the cash, i know from MA's track record the funds wouldnt spent on players so i see no loss at all. Can you outline that record for me please?..