very daft thing to say
didn't you say you considered Milner a fantastic player a while back
BigAl's comment is fair enough. Robert was far too inconsistent to be regarded as a great player. Brilliant on his day but not enough of them most of which was down to him not being arsed.
ah well, going by that logic 'his day' must have occured in 9 out of 10 games during the 03-04 season