Ronaldo

fuck sake man play wingers on the wing. Geremi's as much a winger as my left nut Given BEYE Cacapa Coloccini Enrique Duff Guthrie Geremi Jonas Owen Xisco tempted to put Bassong at CB but I still rate Cacapa as a CB. N'zogbia for Duff anol but he's starting to look like Dyer at his absolute worst

just got back, absolute worst. When the 2nd goal went in there was a tragic moment when it seemed everyone in the gallowgate including myself went for a pint with their resigned indifference. Given 7 Taylor 4 Coloccini 5 Cacapa 6 Bassong 6 Geremi 4 Butt 5 N'zogbia 5 Duff 7 Xisco 5 Owen 6 Xisco's effort was good but he's still well of the pace, the passing was generally an absolute disgrace and I actually feel sorry for Shay Given now. Shocking

aye I was thinking that

Shearer could be just like Souness, he has the same sort of playing mentality which Souness had as a player and I worry that he might be too arrogant to recognise his own weaknesses. Possibly... but Shearer changed his game as he aged. He knew when it was time to retire. I think Shearer will be well aware of any weakness he has and find a way around them. Are you having laugh!. He should have retired three seasons earlier. He was still effective - and our best attacking option - right up until the last season... you know, that extra season he was begged to play. not really, in his last 2 seasons he was awful. Dont forget he didn't manage a single league away goal from open play in 2004

I wonder if they all would welcome Keegan back. all except Ameobi you'd think

sack the fans

Taylor isn't a Colo or a Boumsong, it's being kind to compare him to either despite the latter being woeful

To be fair, most people on here at least seem to recognise Taylor is fairly s***, apart from Northern Monkey who is a psycho. A lot of us were annoyed that Faye was allowed to leave as well but that's history now. And Kaka was one of the biggest Ashleyites professing what a great job was done this summer with the transfer window. Even started a thread about how much he still loved the man. Yet this is the squad his much vaunted system has left us with. And btw for perspective, Collocini has been no better than Taylor over the last few games, they've both been absolutely horrendous. I disagree, Coloccini to be fair seems to have the basics right, he just needs to fine tune his game to the english style which will take a while Taylor has managed to play 4 games out of 6 now without slightly resembling a premiership defender, despite this being his 6th season in the first team. Absolutely shocking

people are forgetting that Bassong is younger and already better than Taylor

just read this sick shit on another site, hope it's all bollocks

nutters

Keane tries too hard with the tough guy act, it's bordering on pathetic to be honest

shit against Bolton shit against Arsenal shit against West Ham shit against Spurs 4 games out of 6 man, you have to wonder when people are just gonna hold their hands up and admit that he's the future of fuck all, certainly not nufc

Butt was his usual pathetic self

credit to Bassong, pretty impressed with him, asserts himself like he's an established first teamer

Bramble ocassionally looked like a footballer though

way way out of his depth, fucking joke of a defender

shut up man

Taylor makes mistakes in every fucking game man open your eyes

Keane comes across a very insecure person. Always trying to seem brutally honest and outspoken to the point it's just daft

without fail. Yet some fools on here would still rather put his development before the team Hilarious how this and other similar myths continue getting churned out every time Taylor is mentioned. Who the f*** does, honestly? The same as when people "excuse Taylor cos he's a Geordie", that's utter toss n'all. He gets slated on here more than many other players in our squad. York a lot of people on here (and especially at the game) are happy for him to be in the team, it's nowt short of madness. How many times does he want to let us down Everything you post on here is exaggerated horribly. You have said you think Cacapa is 5 times the player Taylor is and Ronaldo (obese crock legend one) would still be 10 times better than Viduka. Get some f***ing perspective. I also admitted both were exaggerations so I dont know what your point is. Ronaldo would be comfortably better than Viduka. An overweight Ronaldo still scores goals when you give him the ball, Viduka only does it against the lesser defences

without fail. Yet some fools on here would still rather put his development before the team Hilarious how this and other similar myths continue getting churned out every time Taylor is mentioned. Who the f*** does, honestly? The same as when people "excuse Taylor cos he's a Geordie", that's utter toss n'all. He gets slated on here more than many other players in our squad. York a lot of people on here (and especially at the game) are happy for him to be in the team, it's nowt short of madness. How many times does he want to let us down

maybe? Coloccini turned his back, but the ball was already in the net just about. They can never be a great defensive duo when one of them is s**** and hasn't improved since he was 19 good before West Ham? so you're forgetting the fact that Taylor was shocking against Arsenal and Bolton