Yes, but don't you see? It's two starts. Two. After coming back from an injury. It's not enough.
Maybe if he'd have started every game, was completely recovered, and hadn't scored - then, yes, you'd have a point. You really haven't given him enough time. I mean, seriously, what would you do exile him to the reserves forever? "Sorry Andy, I know you've just come back from injury, those 2 starts aren't good enough". Or do you give the man, who was scoring for fun at this level, a few games and more time to find his form.