Tiresias

Nice tackle bigi

Can they shut up about Liverpools 'revolution' Revolution Number 9-The Beatles

Amalfitano eager to cross, not got range right yet

Sammy has definately bulked up should have more body strength

Good start

That shirt...

£15m is waaaaaaaaaaaaay too high even if true

Remember how annoying it was when Ben Arfa got injured in pre season last year.

Looking forward to see that midfield

They were never going to be able to offload him easily and one would expect they hoped to make some discreet inquiries round to see if anyone wanted him, suspect NUFC kinda thought they could get BRINGING OUR BOY BACK HOME publicity and made a silly offer and have made it impossible for liverpool to conduct their business on the quiet. Think they rather walked into this one, they shouldn't have offered him back, but offered him to West Ham and other clubs, still may have happened, and I may be completely wrong.

Now that's setting the transfer window alight!

I'm not against another striker for when Cisse and Ba are away, it's just the wrong style. At best Carrol would be a plan B for when we're struggling, do we really want that to become plan a for a few months?

Dembele would be ace, not sure Fulham would sell easy though

I was crying because we didn't have enough bodies in midfield when we were being outpossessioned, besides that wasn't that much of an issue by the end, swansea 2-0 win was great

this

I think there are strikers who would suit us better out there for £10m.

Better score a goal at least this time

It's cos he's very good but too much of a gamble for any especially good sides

What would happen is all talk about his redemption then he'd be on the bench loads and all the talk about newcastle would be talk of AC flopping

Detective Homer Simpson - "and thats the end of that chapter"

I'm coming round to the idea of having him on loan for a year, but even for £10m he's a downgrade on a decent ball playing £10m striker who can play on the wing, which is what I'd prefer to have.

It'd be an honour hilarious to see danny playing being quickly benched for chelsea

To be fair coming round to it a bit, just don't think he'll do much and there'll be a media circus around it.

Pards said we would be not a week ago be dominating teams with tika taka Don't think it's so simple as 4-4-2 suiting carroll, we have completely unsuitable wide players.

It's not that I don't rate Carroll, I just think to be effective he needs a team built a certain way and not sure we have the squad to adapt the whole thing for his benefit occiasionally, or we'll end up trying to mix the two styles loads and have ben arfa running into andy carrol half the time