Would you want Keegan back now?

[Frazzle]

I'd be on his back right away

 

Whatever gets the job done. Keegan sex tape, sell it to the Sun, Keegan walks out again. Win.

 

So even if you weren't happy with his appointment you wouldn't want him to stay?  You'd rather he was out A.S.A.P? Weird.

[madras]

i wouldn't.

 

not due to whats happened, i just think he's shot as a top flight manager. he seems too reliant on needing big money to bring players in. the keegan of his first 3 years here doesn't, i fear,exist anymore.

 

Once he had time to implement his tactics he managed to turn our team around without any new players.

 

Oh yeah, actually he did sign Diatta.

he did. but i don't think he'd be happy with that and would want more money than we,or the vast majority of clubs can give.

[cp40]

i wouldn't.

 

not due to whats happened, i just think he's shot as a top flight manager. he seems too reliant on needing big money to bring players in. the keegan of his first 3 years here doesn't, i fear,exist anymore.

 

Once he had time to implement his tactics he managed to turn our team around without any new players.

 

Oh yeah, actually he did sign Diatta.

he did. but i don't think he'd be happy with that and would want more money than we,or the vast majority of clubs can give.

 

 

to spend on you tube?

[SEMTEX]

I'd be on his back right away

 

Whatever gets the job done. Keegan sex tape, sell it to the Sun, Keegan walks out again. Win.

 

So even if you weren't happy with his appointment you wouldn't want him to stay?  You'd rather he was out A.S.A.P? Weird.

 

Ultimately, if he got appointed, I'd get on with supporting NUFC, but wouldn't actively support/the-opposite-of-support Mr.Keegan.

 

I'm not really planning to sell a Keegan sex tape you know..

[madras]

i wouldn't.

 

not due to whats happened, i just think he's shot as a top flight manager. he seems too reliant on needing big money to bring players in. the keegan of his first 3 years here doesn't, i fear,exist anymore.

 

Once he had time to implement his tactics he managed to turn our team around without any new players.

 

Oh yeah, actually he did sign Diatta.

he did. but i don't think he'd be happy with that and would want more money than we,or the vast majority of clubs can give.

 

 

to spend on you tube?

thats not gonna die is it ? you probably think we were actually scouting on youtube instead of getting in a player as soome way to butter up some agents.

[Frazzle]

I'd be on his back right away

 

Whatever gets the job done. Keegan sex tape, sell it to the Sun, Keegan walks out again. Win.

 

So even if you weren't happy with his appointment you wouldn't want him to stay?  You'd rather he was out A.S.A.P? Weird.

 

Ultimately, if he got appointed, I'd get on with supporting NUFC, but wouldn't actively support/the-opposite-of-support Mr.Keegan.

 

I'm not really planning to sell a Keegan sex tape you know..

 

I know that.    It just seemed that was your general attitude regardless of that joke, which I knew was a joke!  

 

I think...

[johnnypd]

People really think that taking on Keegan would be a good idea, when thousands of Newcastle fans would oppose it?

 

that's as bad as saying we should appoint someone because the fans would like it. that shouldn't really come into it.

 

Nonsense - it helps when the fans back an appointment ( for the converse see Souness G)  and KK has a wee bit of history!

 

if you think im saying it doesn't help then you've misunderstood me. Im saying it shouldnt really be part of the club's criteria when appointing a manager. arsenal didnt turn round and say 'hang on lads, the crowd will be baffled by this wenger bloke from japan, let's go back to rioch'. Souness being unpopular had pretty much fuck all to do with him being failure, which was entirely down to the fact he was a shit manager. the reason people didnt want him here was also down to the fact he was a shit manager. had he done well the initial disgust would've been quickly forgotten, like when bellamy was signed by Robson, as an example.

[Dave]

i wouldn't.

 

not due to whats happened, i just think he's shot as a top flight manager. he seems too reliant on needing big money to bring players in. the keegan of his first 3 years here doesn't, i fear,exist anymore.

 

Once he had time to implement his tactics he managed to turn our team around without any new players.

 

Oh yeah, actually he did sign Diatta.

he did. but i don't think he'd be happy with that and would want more money than we,or the vast majority of clubs can give.

 

 

to spend on you tube?

thats not gonna die is it ? you probably think we were actually scouting on youtube instead of getting in a player as soome way to butter up some agents.

 

Pretty disgraceful either way. £1,000,000 for a fucking potential favour.

[cp40]

i wouldn't.

 

not due to whats happened, i just think he's shot as a top flight manager. he seems too reliant on needing big money to bring players in. the keegan of his first 3 years here doesn't, i fear,exist anymore.

 

Once he had time to implement his tactics he managed to turn our team around without any new players.

 

Oh yeah, actually he did sign Diatta.

he did. but i don't think he'd be happy with that and would want more money than we,or the vast majority of clubs can give.

 

 

to spend on you tube?

thats not gonna die is it ? you probably think we were actually scouting on youtube instead of getting in a player as soome way to butter up some agents.

 

 

so for a million a year, Wise recomends players via you tube...........nice work if you can get it.

[madras]

i wouldn't.

 

not due to whats happened, i just think he's shot as a top flight manager. he seems too reliant on needing big money to bring players in. the keegan of his first 3 years here doesn't, i fear,exist anymore.

 

Once he had time to implement his tactics he managed to turn our team around without any new players.

 

Oh yeah, actually he did sign Diatta.

he did. but i don't think he'd be happy with that and would want more money than we,or the vast majority of clubs can give.

 

 

to spend on you tube?

thats not gonna die is it ? you probably think we were actually scouting on youtube instead of getting in a player as soome way to butter up some agents.

 

Pretty disgraceful either way. £1,000,000 for a f***ing potential favour.

as i've said i hope the authorities are on to it.

[madras]

i wouldn't.

 

not due to whats happened, i just think he's shot as a top flight manager. he seems too reliant on needing big money to bring players in. the keegan of his first 3 years here doesn't, i fear,exist anymore.

 

Once he had time to implement his tactics he managed to turn our team around without any new players.

 

Oh yeah, actually he did sign Diatta.

he did. but i don't think he'd be happy with that and would want more money than we,or the vast majority of clubs can give.

 

 

to spend on you tube?

thats not gonna die is it ? you probably think we were actually scouting on youtube instead of getting in a player as soome way to butter up some agents.

 

 

so for a million a year, Wise recomends players via you tube...........nice work if you can get it.

he didn't recommend a player via you tube. he probably hadn't even seen him onin there or anywhere else before...IT WAS A SCAM TO BUTTER UP SOME AGENTS.

[johnnypd]

the club admitted that none of them had seen Nacho so yeah, whatever the motivation behind the deal, they DID end up having to rely on youtube as a scouting tool.

[madras]

the club admitted that none of them had seen Nacho so yeah, whatever the motivation behind the deal, they DID end up having to rely on youtube as a scouting tool.

even if he signed before anyone hit the search button ?

[Thespence]

The Youtube footage which is on this persons profile http://www.youtube.com/user/00osa00 has awesome write up "gnacio Gonzalez, know as "Nacho" Gonzalez could be likened to Valderrama & Zinedine Zidane because he always has an ace in the hole. The elegance of his moves define a playmaker.."

 

After watching the clip I would get the lad in as he looks better than Guthrie or the player I am squinting at does.

 

Even though he didn't have the final say it was nice of Den to at least tell Kev about the player.

[SteveMc]

But legally that would be fine.  It's just a matter of laoning a player - with a view to the same agents hopefully getting you some good uns in future. 

 

Bad for the club, aye.  Illegal, ney

[midds]

i wouldn't.

 

not due to whats happened, i just think he's shot as a top flight manager. he seems too reliant on needing big money to bring players in. the keegan of his first 3 years here doesn't, i fear,exist anymore.

 

Once he had time to implement his tactics he managed to turn our team around without any new players.

 

Oh yeah, actually he did sign Diatta.

he did. but i don't think he'd be happy with that and would want more money than we,or the vast majority of clubs can give.

 

 

to spend on you tube?

thats not gonna die is it ? you probably think we were actually scouting on youtube instead of getting in a player as soome way to butter up some agents.

 

Pretty disgraceful either way. £1,000,000 for a fucking potential favour.

 

As out of order as that is, I'd be willing to bet things like that happen all of the time. Just most clubs manage to keep a lid on it.....

[johnnypd]

the club admitted that none of them had seen Nacho so yeah, whatever the motivation behind the deal, they DID end up having to rely on youtube as a scouting tool.

even if he signed before anyone hit the search button ?

 

i dont think it matters really, though i'd imagine the now infamous video of Nacho, or pixels purporting to be him, was watched before the signing was confirmed.

[Thespence]

the club admitted that none of them had seen Nacho so yeah, whatever the motivation behind the deal, they DID end up having to rely on youtube as a scouting tool.

even if he signed before anyone hit the search button ?

 

Nacho was signed on 31/08 according to the PDF,  Den & Kev were talking about Nacho on 30/08 according to the PDF.

[Dave]

i wouldn't.

 

not due to whats happened, i just think he's shot as a top flight manager. he seems too reliant on needing big money to bring players in. the keegan of his first 3 years here doesn't, i fear,exist anymore.

 

Once he had time to implement his tactics he managed to turn our team around without any new players.

 

Oh yeah, actually he did sign Diatta.

he did. but i don't think he'd be happy with that and would want more money than we,or the vast majority of clubs can give.

 

 

to spend on you tube?

thats not gonna die is it ? you probably think we were actually scouting on youtube instead of getting in a player as soome way to butter up some agents.

 

Pretty disgraceful either way. £1,000,000 for a fucking potential favour.

 

As out of order as that is, I'd be willing to bet things like that happen all of the time. Just most clubs manage to keep a lid on it.....

 

Oh aye, and the tribunal says that though Keegan thought it was wrong (regardless of the imposing a player shit) they didn't see a particular problem with the principle.

 

Fucking stinks IMO.

[madras]

the club admitted that none of them had seen Nacho so yeah, whatever the motivation behind the deal, they DID end up having to rely on youtube as a scouting tool.

even if he signed before anyone hit the search button ?

 

Nacho was signed on 31/08 according to the PDF,  Den & Kev were talking about Nacho on 30/08 according to the PDF.

and it would have been agreed before he signed.

 

it was a favout to some agents,probably worse than finding a player on youtube anyway.

[Dave]

the club admitted that none of them had seen Nacho so yeah, whatever the motivation behind the deal, they DID end up having to rely on youtube as a scouting tool.

even if he signed before anyone hit the search button ?

 

How would Wise know he was on YouTube if he didn't look first?

 

He told KK to look on there the day before we signed him.

[madras]

the club admitted that none of them had seen Nacho so yeah, whatever the motivation behind the deal, they DID end up having to rely on youtube as a scouting tool.

even if he signed before anyone hit the search button ?

 

How would Wise know he was on YouTube if he didn't look first?

 

He told KK to look on there the day before we signed him.

"dennis, we are getting in jgnacio gonzalez as a favour to some agents"

 

dennis turns youporn off "may aswell have a look at him"

[Dave]

the club admitted that none of them had seen Nacho so yeah, whatever the motivation behind the deal, they DID end up having to rely on youtube as a scouting tool.

even if he signed before anyone hit the search button ?

 

How would Wise know he was on YouTube if he didn't look first?

 

He told KK to look on there the day before we signed him.

"dennis, we are getting in jgnacio gonzalez as a favour to some agents"

 

dennis turns youporn off "may aswell have a look at him"

 

'Mr Wise telephoned Mr Keegan and told him that he had a great player for the Club to sign, namely Ignacio Gonzalez, and that he should look him up.'

 

[cp40]

the club admitted that none of them had seen Nacho so yeah, whatever the motivation behind the deal, they DID end up having to rely on youtube as a scouting tool.

even if he signed before anyone hit the search button ?

 

How would Wise know he was on YouTube if he didn't look first?

 

He told KK to look on there the day before we signed him.

 

 

maybe thats why his eyes went all wonky from watching too many Youtubes?

[Guest BlacknWhiteArmy]

If Keegan was re-appointed manager, yes I'd support him and the club, but I'm not sure I'd be too impressed. This club needs to go forwards. Not backwards.