STM

I actually believe that Dyer could save Roeders career... for a while. We need someone like Dyer to inject some energy into the team. I'd love to see him and Martins up front together!

Completely forgot to put him in mine. Great shout mate. Not so sure about Carr but then again i was tempted to put in Ramage. bluebiggrin.gif

Don't get me wrong, he isn't and will never be as good as Scholes at his peak. However, his late runs and goals contributions are very similar.

Just to get away from the misery that is our football club. I thought i'd take this opportunity to see who you have been impressed with so far. Your players and reasons are entirely up to you. Here's mine: GK- James. Since moving to Portsmouth he seems to have cut out his errors, might be to do with Pompey's defence though. DF-Campbell. I thought he was past his best but has proven me and quite a few wrong for us failing to sign him. DF-Mellberg. Always a competant defender but has flourished under O'Neill. The rock in a solid back four. DF-Baines. Some good defending and and stunning goals. Left back for the future without a doubt. DF-Evra. I was convinced he would fail after his appaling start at Man U but has come on leaps and bounds. Deserves credit for bouncing back. MF-Giggs. Pains me to say it but age certainly isn't catching up with giggs. May not be at his unbelievable best still performing on the worlds biggest stage. MF-Speed. Similarly to Giggs is still churning out the performances in the premiership. Although, i'm slightly biast. bluewink.gif MF-Essien. Another player coming on leaps and bounds. How long before he's Chelsea's most important player, not long i suspect, if he gets a few more goals. MF-Cahill. God i hate the little Ozzy runt. However, he is one of the main reasons why Everton are picking up so many points. Reminds me of scholes of old..... sadly. FW- Andy Johnson. The other reason why Everton are picking up points..... enough said. FW-Drogba. Just beat Saha because he's cut out his diving. Who would have thought he make Sheva look average. Your comments and your suggestions?

Benitez is a fine manager, when you compare houlliers liverpool to his. Think he's one of the best but in the bracket just below messers fergie, wenger and mourinho.

SJH and Freddie are just two average chairman, both of which have hired one good manager a piece. On the one hand SJH, as Ne5 says, got lucky with a hit or miss keegan appointment. On the other, Freddie hired Robson who was always going to improve our club but was it inspired or just plain obvious? I'd also like to remind a few that Freddie nearly Bolloxed that up by offering him embarrassing wages. We've spent 100's of millions down the years on players, which shows great amition. However, am i the only one that would have preffered us to throw the boat and get in a world class manager, instead of signing numours trophy players to appease the fans. A good manager doesn't need the luxury of multi millions to make a club successfull, look at Wenger. That's how to run a club! When will we learn that managers make clubs a success not players?

That's two flooked goals in two games for Zamora. Technically he has only scored 3 intentional goals this season. bluewink.gif

Jeezus...now the "every Newcastle fans a bad supporter but me" prats are at it. If you're happy with this Roeder/Shepherd shambles, that doesn't make you or the other one good supporters, just gullible. :roll: Just because he supports Roeder doesn't make him a know it all or a arogent fan.

I really "hope" there is a takeover, Shepherds popularity rating is at an all time low, the word incompetent springs to mind for the one-millionth time when describing our leader It's always the same though isn't it. Right now people are talking about what a moron he is, yet last month they were hailing the signings of Duff and Martins. It would be no suprise to me if we signed Bridge and another good player in january, then everyones saying what a wonderfull chairman he is. I agree, Remember last year he was getting booed at the 1st game but after we got Luque,Owen and Solano his name was being chanted. Its funny because the pundits always say Newcastle fans are the most forgiving. Forgiving or fickle? There are very few Newcastle fans that i have met don't in some way change there opinion when the going gets tough. Just look at the way peoples opinion has changed of Roeder in the last few hours. Never mind days. I for one am fully backing the manager and the talented players we have in the squad. We needed a couple more players and we haven't got them, boo hoo lets just crack on. you said it not me :winking: It does make me laugh when they say it because i know what they realy wanna say but your right most fans are fickle in there own way, Ive been known to change my opinion from time to time. Im backing the manager, Roeder has taken on a massive job after Souness left and people expected him to sort it all out this transfer window on little transfer money. The only thing im slightly disappointed about is the fact that we didnt streghten the full back areas, We got Bernard but that wasnt the player we all were hoping for. I'm not pretending i don't do it. When we signed Owen, apart of me wanted chant "there's only one freddy sheppard", but i refrained when i remember how he got rid of Bobby and all the other countless mishaps he has had. If Roeder had set out to sign Bernard in the first place there would not have been as much a problem. The problem was that he left it late and proved he failed in the transfer market with his number one targets. At least we have cover in that position shame we're short of a centre back now.

I really "hope" there is a takeover, Shepherds popularity rating is at an all time low, the word incompetent springs to mind for the one-millionth time when describing our leader It's always the same though isn't it. Right now people are talking about what a moron he is, yet last month they were hailing the signings of Duff and Martins. It would be no suprise to me if we signed Bridge and another good player in january, then everyones saying what a wonderfull chairman he is. I agree, Remember last year he was getting booed at the 1st game but after we got Luque,Owen and Solano his name was being chanted. Its funny because the pundits always say Newcastle fans are the most forgiving. Forgiving or fickle? There are very few Newcastle fans that i have met don't in some way change there opinion when the going gets tough. Just look at the way peoples opinion has changed of Roeder in the last few hours. Never mind days. I for one am fully backing the manager and the talented players we have in the squad. We needed a couple more players and we haven't got them, boo hoo lets just crack on.

I really "hope" there is a takeover, Shepherds popularity rating is at an all time low, the word incompetent springs to mind for the one-millionth time when describing our leader It's always the same though isn't it. Right now people are talking about what a moron he is, yet last month they were hailing the signings of Duff and Martins. It would be no suprise to me if we signed Bridge and another good player in january, then everyones saying what a wonderfull chairman he is.

Everyone was moaning about the lack of height in our team, problem solved You say it in jest. Roeder is serious. blueeek.gif Not to fussed about sibierski, as long as Ameobi, Martins and Rossi get in the team before he does.

There's no gaurantees with any of them. I really am baffled how you can think we're better off now than last year. We've signed an admittedly good winger who we didn't need. We were already covered in that position with N'Zogbia and as you say O'Brien. Rossi's only here for 4 months and will then **** off regardless if he's any good or not. The way we operate in the transfer market we're likely to go the whole of January at least a striker down before we get a replacement. Sibierski is gash. I wouldn't swap him for anyone! You say that Shearer did little but hold the ball up. Maybe so, but who the hell is going to hold the ball up now? Out of the players we don't have Shearers holding up the ball skill is the one we will miss the most but we will have to do without. Our midfield has improved considerably since last year with the progress of the Zog, the return of milner and Duff signing. As for the defence, i really wish we had brought in a replacment for Boumsong but that said we are no worse off without him. Once people calm down, i hope they will look at our whole squad and realise we have a plethora of talent.

***Cracks open bottle of bubbly**** Why is it you miss out everything else i've said? I was argueing that we have a better squad than we had last year, i was using them in my arguement. Don't pretend like you are old enough to consume alcohol. Does your dad mind you using his computer this late. Hope you don't find his porn.

Oh and i forgot we now have a youth system with players such as Patterson, O'Brien and Huntington coming through.

Wey i don't blame you for not acting like a little girl like half of these lot. Listen i love my football, i also love coming on here and reading peoples views as well as giving my opinion. However, in the last couple of days i've seen some idiotic knee-jerk reactions by people. Siberski is a wank signing but our lives are not in danger so why don't people just grow up and stop swearing like immature little girls. Newcastle United have a group of players most clubs would die for. There are few positions that need carefull attention that has not been seen to but we have a FAR better squad than last year and i'm delighted at the job roeder has done. FALSE. Rewind a year we had Bowyer, Shearer, Chopra, Boumsong (not great but a body) in the squad. Plus a fit Owen. Bowyer: Outragously inconsistant. Shearer: Forgetting what a lengend he was, he offered us very little but the fact he could hold up a ball. Chopra: Not good enough Boumsong: Your correct he wasn't great therefore should not have been a body in the squad. Faye: You missed, he's shite. A fit Owen: like saying a fit dyer Now if your saying would i swap Bowyer, Shearer, Chopra, Boumsong, and and faye for Martins, Duff, Rossi (loan) Milner, Butt and Sibierski . I would have said thank you very much. With a similar squad we finished 7th dispite having a useless manager for half a year. I have no doubt we are capable of reaching that again, if not further.

Wey i don't blame you for not acting like a little girl like half of these lot. Listen i love my football, i also love coming on here and reading peoples views as well as giving my opinion. However, in the last couple of days i've seen some idiotic knee-jerk reactions by people. Siberski is a wank signing but our lives are not in danger so why don't people just grow up and stop swearing like immature little girls. Newcastle United have a group of players most clubs would die for. There are few positions that need carefull attention that has not been seen to but we have a FAR better squad than last year and i'm delighted at the job roeder has done.

Not if he's reading about Newcastle. He'll be saying "what the fuck have we bought that french toss pot for".

Transfers is just a very small part of Management. I hope for glenn sake he can pick up results with thegroup of players that we have. People please don't forget that we have a fantastic midfield and a decent set of strikers. It's the defence i'm worrying about.

Done that for another half hour and you will be where i'am at. Unlike some of these lot, i'm not going to go and throw me self off a bridge. We have a cracking group of player with a few areas of weakness. Sibierski was a needless signing but who knows what roeders planning.

Sibierski is shit. We all know that, know one needs to point it out. However, he's tall and shit. He's tall and shit and can head the ball. Ok im done. bluebiggrin.gif

Is another word for one's rear end! bluewink.gif

I agree. This is more the standard i expect Roeder to be after.

However, Chelsea know that at any second Cole could be theirs if they bid the money asked. I believe, they may get rid of Bridge to help fund the Cole situation. My point is that they could get rid of Bridge before Cole joins them, fingers crossed.

May i reiterate that when lamb said Viduka is staying, what he really meant was " we want more money". Remember Fred last year said that Milner was going no where and about six hours later he was a villa player on loan.