Perch was nervous as hell at the start, but started looking alright as the game progressed.
Smith on the other hand is essentially culpable for at least, half the goals they scored and the utter domination they had over our midfield. Smith didn't track any runs, didn't try to intercept any passes, didn't offer himself for passes and the space he gave Scholes ... well we may as well have played Barton alone in midfield, because that would have prevented Smith from trying to break Rooney's rut at least.