I feel like a jackass even attempting to contribute to this thread, but in my limited time, I have to say the 3-2 vs Tottenham has to be high point in my time as a fan. Going beyond Martins' unbelievable strike, a goal so unexpected I was out of my seat screaming like a girl before I even understood that the ball went in. I loved that Butt got the winner after the confrontation with Chimbonda. After the goal, when he was jogging backwards with all the players chasing him, you couldn't get the grin off my face.
Pales in comparison to the things I've read here, but it's all I have.