Pope clearly has the better defence in front of him and has only been here half a season. But he does command his box so much better and his shot stopping seems just as good as Given’s. Given did have a tendency to struggle due to his height imo. He was pretty short for a goalkeeper.
However, Given had a dreadful defence in front of him, even when we were good
Bernard O’Brien/Dabizas/Cauldwell/Woodgate/Bramble/Boumsong Griffin/Hughes
My gut says Pope is a better keeper. But like others have said it might take another 18 months for it to be unequivocal.