-
Posts
8,780 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Everything posted by Collage
-
No. The Man U job is one of the top 3-5 in football. David Moyes shouldn’t have gotten it, he wasn’t qualified. The same goes for Solskjaer. Shearer took over from Joe Kinnear And we knew that was the road we were heading down again. Of course we wanted Shearer to stay. Not comparable. Absolutely comparable. As much as it disgusts me to say it, Joe Kinnear was on paper much more qualified than Alan Shearer to manage Newcastle United if you look at their managerial history and not their attachment to any one club. Shearer wasn't even a manager at the time, what would your opinion be if Gary Lineker was the one appointed and not Shearer? Would you have wanted Lineker to get the job, or stay? Jaime Redknapp? Pochettino is essentially just as qualified on paper for the Man Utd job as Moyes was. It's a bit of a double standard if you say Moyes shouldn't have gotten the job, yet you think Pochettino should get it when you look at their managerial history up until the point Moyes took over Man Utd, or Pochettino now if he took over tomorrow. Neither have major honors, and their biggest achievements have been building a club that didn't compete much into a team that could compete. The Barcelona job is perhaps the biggest job in football, that went to a reserve team manager. In the end, the manager needs to be a proper fit for a club. Look, if you think Mourinho to OGS and Kinnear to Shearer is a good comparison, there’s nothing more I can say really. It’s just ridiculous. I’d take Lineker or Redknapp over Kinnear, yes. I’d take pretty much anybody over him. How is this relevant? I haven’t mentioned Pochettino. You're (I assume) intentionally misinterpreting my comparisons. Zidane following Benitez then? Why is that different to OGS following Mourinho? We as NUFC fans inherently dislike OGS due to his horrid behavior against us. We don't have that dislike for Zidane, for instance. It's not over Kinnear, it's how you'd react if they were appointed following Kinnear (and not Shearer). You'd naturally would have wanted us to appoint a manager with experience, not a pundit. Yet, due to us loving Shearer, we welcomed him as a savior, when he did not even have any coaching badges and supported him - yet say OGS shouldn't be at Man Utd when he's more qualified for the Man Utd job than Shearer was for the NUFC job. We'd be absolutely livid if they'd appointed Lineker or Jaime Redknapp, yet om paper they're just as qualified as Shearer with their main jobs since they retired being pundits. I brought up Pochettino to make a new point and comparison to back my original point in our discussion. I don’t think Zidane was qualified for the Real job although I can understand why he got it at the time, and of course it worked. The job at hand at Man U is a whole different matter. In my opinion they need a meticulous manager who can make the sum bigger than its parts, given the material. OGS is probably a good man manager but there’s no clear structure, it’s a bit hit and miss.
-
No. The Man U job is one of the top 3-5 in football. David Moyes shouldn’t have gotten it, he wasn’t qualified. The same goes for Solskjaer. Shearer took over from Joe Kinnear And we knew that was the road we were heading down again. Of course we wanted Shearer to stay. Not comparable. Absolutely comparable. As much as it disgusts me to say it, Joe Kinnear was on paper much more qualified than Alan Shearer to manage Newcastle United if you look at their managerial history and not their attachment to any one club. Shearer wasn't even a manager at the time, what would your opinion be if Gary Lineker was the one appointed and not Shearer? Would you have wanted Lineker to get the job, or stay? Jaime Redknapp? Pochettino is essentially just as qualified on paper for the Man Utd job as Moyes was. It's a bit of a double standard if you say Moyes shouldn't have gotten the job, yet you think Pochettino should get it when you look at their managerial history up until the point Moyes took over Man Utd, or Pochettino now if he took over tomorrow. Neither have major honors, and their biggest achievements have been building a club that didn't compete much into a team that could compete. The Barcelona job is perhaps the biggest job in football, that went to a reserve team manager. In the end, the manager needs to be a proper fit for a club. Look, if you think Mourinho to OGS and Kinnear to Shearer is a good comparison, there’s nothing more I can say really. It’s just ridiculous. I’d take Lineker or Redknapp over Kinnear, yes. I’d take pretty much anybody over him. How is this relevant? I haven’t mentioned Pochettino.
-
No. The Man U job is one of the top 3-5 in football. David Moyes shouldn’t have gotten it, he wasn’t qualified. The same goes for Solskjaer. Shearer took over from Joe Kinnear And we knew that was the road we were heading down again. Of course we wanted Shearer to stay. Not comparable. Absolutely comparable. Joe Kinnear was on paper much more qualified than Alan Shearer to manage Newcastle United if you look at their managerial history and not attachment to any one club. You have to be fucking joking, seriously.
-
No. The Man U job is one of the top 3-5 in football. David Moyes shouldn’t have gotten it, he wasn’t qualified. The same goes for Solskjaer. Shearer took over from Joe Kinnear And we knew that was the road we were heading down again. Of course we wanted Shearer to stay. Not comparable.
-
Great from Fernandez. Deserved a goal.
-
I wouldn’t count them out yet
-
Fantastic I’m out for a while
-
So without James and Richarlison Everton really have nothing when it comes to creating chances then
-
My feelings exactly
-
never a penalty
-
All our games look like this.
-
Relatable
-
Even when we're set up with attacking players we reek of fear. Everything is safety first and it starts from the back where the defenders look absolutely terrified in possession. Yeah, we clearly have the players to play some decent stuff.
-
Our games are always horrible to watch.
-
Oh yes. Top of the premiership.
-
One of my favourite goals
-
I’d say he’s been the best player in the league so far.
-
Great from Neville there