Jump to content

Silly Money Thresholds


afar
 Share

Recommended Posts

This is not a thread about perceived value of players, I repeat this is not an estimated value of players thread.

 

What kind of bid do you think should be accepted for our current players assuming someone ponies up the lolly?

 

Factor in potential, resale value, off the field issues, squad depth, injury records and the ability to replace the player.

 

Here’s my list:

 

GK

 

Harper – 5 million

Krul – 7.5 million

Forster – 10 million

 

Def

 

R.Taylor – 2 million

Simpson – 3 million

Enrique – 25 million

S Taylor – 15 Million

Collocini – 15 million

Williamson -  8 million

Kadar – 8 million

 

Mid

 

Barton – 3 million

Smith – 2 million

Guthrie – 12 million

Jonas – 15 million

Routledge – 10 million

Nolan – 5 million

 

Fwd

 

Shola – 3 million

Loven – 3 million

Best – 1 million

Carroll – 20 million

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Finding it a little confusing the response so far, it's a legit topic, purely speculation, thought I would try to liven up this dead board at the moment, guess that's not really appreciated, sorry for wasting your time clicking on the subject, thought there might have been some debate here, every player has a price we could be tempted to sell him for.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest toonlass

This is not a thread about perceived value of players, I repeat this is not an estimated value of players thread.

 

What kind of bid do you think should be accepted for our current players assuming someone ponies up the lolly?

 

Factor in potential, resale value, off the field issues, squad depth, injury records and the ability to replace the player.

 

Here’s my list:

 

GK

 

Harper – 5 million

Krul – 7.5 million

Forster – 10 million

 

Def

 

R.Taylor – 2 million

Simpson – 3 million

Enrique – 25 million

S Taylor – 15 Million

Collocini – 15 million

Wilkinson -  8 million  WHO?????

Kadar – 8 million

 

Mid

 

Barton – 3 million

Smith – 2 million

Guthrie – 12 million

Jonas – 15 million

Routledge – 10 million

Nolan – 5 million

 

Fwd

 

Shola – 3 million

Loven – 3 million

Best – 1 million

Carroll – 20 million

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Updated it with my quick guesses but kept them quite low.

 

 

GK

 

Harper – 2/3 million

Krul – 3 million

Forster – 1.5/2 million (lesser known name than Krul)

 

Def

 

R.Taylor – 2 million

Simpson – 3 million

Enrique – 4 million

S Taylor – 6 Million

Collocini – 5 million

Williamson -  3 million

Kadar – 3 million

 

Mid

 

Barton – 3 million

Smith – 2 million

Guthrie – 3 million

Jonas – 7 million

Routledge – 3 million

Nolan – 4 million

 

Fwd

 

Shola – 3 million

Loven – 3 million

Best – 2 million

Carroll – 5/6 million

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

good topic, think some of your estimations might be over the top though

 

Again, this was not in any shape or form meant to be estimates on player value, it's about a threshold that we have to take the money, even if we want to keep the player, because the offer is silly money. For example I'm not saying for a second that Carroll is worth 20 mill or Jose 25 million, but if someone ponies up that amount, it's a no brainer to take it.

Link to post
Share on other sites

This is not a thread about perceived value of players, I repeat this is not an estimated value of players thread.

 

What kind of bid do you think should be accepted for our current players assuming someone ponies up the lolly?

 

Factor in potential, resale value, off the field issues, squad depth, injury records and the ability to replace the player.

 

Heres my list:

 

GK

 

Harper 5 million

Krul 7.5 million

Forster 10 million

 

Def

 

R.Taylor 2 million

Simpson 3 million

Enrique 25 million

S Taylor 15 Million

Collocini 15 million

Wilkinson -  8 million  WHO?????

Kadar 8 million

 

Mid

 

Barton 3 million

Smith 2 million

Guthrie 12 million

Jonas 15 million

Routledge 10 million

Nolan 5 million

 

Fwd

 

Shola 3 million

Loven 3 million

Best 1 million

Carroll 20 million

 

 

Sorry I obviously meant Williamson, getting my willies muddled up :)

Link to post
Share on other sites

Wilkinson, being one of our best ever players, should never be sold.

 

keeps the players chins nice and smooth, i agree

 

Rumours that the blades want him back though.

Link to post
Share on other sites

good topic, think some of your estimations might be over the top though

 

Again, this was not in any shape or form meant to be estimates on player value, it's about a threshold that we have to take the money, even if we want to keep the player, because the offer is silly money. For example I'm not saying for a second that Carroll is worth 20 mill or Jose 25 million, but if someone ponies up that amount, it's a no brainer to take it.

 

absolutley, i'd take 15m for each of them.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...