Dogawful Officiating - Dave Coote suspended

[mattypnufc]

Be nice for a shit decision in terms of 'diving' etc to go our way for once.

 

Also, how come Sterling didn't get booked for diving outside the box at the Leazes?

 

But aye, naive from our players with 'slight' touches on the City players when you know they'll fall over...however there was on point where Diame literally got hugged to the ground and the ref totally ignored it. 

[Rebellious]

I am pretty sure I saw 2 penalties today, 1 for Merino and 1 for Gayle.  Neither clear but on the replays both were contact.

[Guest firetotheworks]

Gayle was a possible, Merino was a definite pen imo. I feel like we'll get one when it isn't a penalty, just to fuck with this ridiculous record we have of being shafted by refs.

[1964]

Neither were pens imo, Gayle’s was another Oscar contender, and Merino stumbled and lost his balance.  We’d be furious if either were given against us.

[Guest neesy111]

Neither were pens imo, Gayle’s was another Oscar contender, and Merino stumbled and lost his balance.  We’d be furious if either were given against us.

 

This.

[Guest firetotheworks]

Neither were pens imo, Gayle’s was another Oscar contender, and Merino stumbled and lost his balance.  We’d be furious if either were given against us.

 

We've had plenty against us like that, because in the modern game, they're often given. The difference is that we don't get these decisions, it's not consigned to us by any means, any team outside of the top 6 is generally less likely to get them. Check out Chelsea's penalty today for an example.

[1964]

Neither were pens imo, Gayle’s was another Oscar contender, and Merino stumbled and lost his balance.  We’d be furious if either were given against us.

 

We've had plenty against us like that, because in the modern game, they're often given. The difference is that we don't get these decisions, it's not consigned to us by any means, any team outside of the top 6 is generally less likely to get them. Check out Chelsea's penalty today for an example.

I agree with this but it doesn’t make them any more penalties, just highlights the bias to the bigger teams

[Guest firetotheworks]

Neither were pens imo, Gayle’s was another Oscar contender, and Merino stumbled and lost his balance.  We’d be furious if either were given against us.

 

We've had plenty against us like that, because in the modern game, they're often given. The difference is that we don't get these decisions, it's not consigned to us by any means, any team outside of the top 6 is generally less likely to get them. Check out Chelsea's penalty today for an example.

I agree with this but it doesn’t make them any more penalties, just highlights the bias to the bigger teams

 

Potato/Potahto when it comes down to it. We haven't had any penalty decision go our way in the PL for 4 years or something. You'd think we'd get a soft one at some point.

[Rebellious]

Neither were pens imo, Gayle’s was another Oscar contender, and Merino stumbled and lost his balance.  We’d be furious if either were given against us.

 

This.

 

I didn`t think either were until I saw the replays.  Maybe I saw it wrong, remembered wrong or just don`t know outside of clear cut what constitutes a penalty anymore.

[Parsley]

Merino's looked clear as day IMO. Had he gone straight down rather than try to stay on his feet and stumble over, I think the ref would've given it. The contact from Bruno looked pretty clear-cut

[Pilko]

Palace and WBA given nothing penalties today. Can see why Gayle is hoying himself over every time he gets the chance, pens get given for anything.

 

Unless you're in a toon top of course.

[Incognito]

Anyhow the OP refers to Mike Dean six years ago and he is still at it. Can only marvel at his longevity of incompetence.

[M4]

Wish Gayle cuts it out though. It's embarrassing.

 

Will gladly take one those West Brom penalties though. That falls from the sky with no one even expecting or appealing for one.

[Incognito]

Dermot Gallagher sticking up for Dean. Saying it's not a pen but he can understand why he's given it. Why is the referee shop such a closed one? Gallagher should say Dean has fucked up big time not tittle-tattle about the where's and why fors.

[Dembacha]

Gayle was a possible, Merino was a definite pen imo. I feel like we'll get one when it isn't a penalty, just to f*** with this ridiculous record we have of being shafted by refs.

 

We'll get one when it has no concequence on the outcome of the game. In injury time when we're 3-0 down or something

[Benwell Lad]

Wenger's correct. Reffing standards haven't improved since they became professional. Might even have gone backwards.

Only been two stand outs during that time and unfortunately they both support Newcastle so we never see them.

 

[Figures 1-0 Football]

Fwiw I thought the referee’s performance on Saturday was the best we’ve had in a long time.

 

Granted there wasn’t a huge amount for him to get right or wrong, but I agreed with most (if not all) of his calls and thought he let the game flow quite well.

[wormy]

Wish Gayle cuts it out though. It's embarrassing.

 

Will gladly take one those West Brom penalties though. That falls from the sky with no one even expecting or appealing for one.

 

Tbh I'm now of the opinion that we need people like Gayle from this perspective. He's one of the few players that argues with the ref, too. For years now, I swear we've had the calmest team in the league as far as putting pressure on a referee. The useless fuckers are too dumb to do the job properly of their own accord, you need to put that pressure on them.

[summerof69]

Jesus christ man that's fucking terrible. FEWMING.

[Guest firetotheworks]

Worst ref I've seen this season by an absolute mile.

[Incognito]

I'm a bit of a drama queen conspiracy theorist but I'm certain refs are told to fuck us over. We rarely if ever benefit from dodgy decisions and indeed don't even get obvious ones. It happens way too much to be coincidence.

[M4]

Wish Gayle cuts it out though. It's embarrassing.

 

Will gladly take one those West Brom penalties though. That falls from the sky with no one even expecting or appealing for one.

 

Tbh I'm now of the opinion that we need people like Gayle from this perspective. He's one of the few players that argues with the ref, too. For years now, I swear we've had the calmest team in the league as far as putting pressure on a referee. The useless fuckers are too dumb to do the job properly of their own accord, you need to put that pressure on them.

All for putting pressure on officials, but not interested in blatant cheats in the team I support.

 

Not seen the incident today, but Gayle's reputation might have cost us a real penalty from reading through the match thread.

[Skeletor]

It was as clear a penalty as there is.

[John P]

Absolutely blatant pen and the decision not to go back and book Allen in the first half was outrageous. Just complete incompetence.

[DJ_NUFC]

Just came in here to post exactly this. It's now getting to the point where I feel like a conspiracy theorist. How long has it been now since we were awarded a penalty? And almost all the shouts for them have been legitimate. Today even the commentator agreed it should've been given. Then you see how opposing players are treated for their absurd, violent challenges, whereas we don't even get the benefit of the doubt. The game is fucking bent.