The Return of Terraces ("safe standing")?

[Yorkie]

New response from government:

 

The Government thanks all the football supporters who made their views known about this issue through correspondence or through the recent online petition. Many of those were concerned that the proposal from West Bromwich Albion FC made earlier this year to install a standing section was rejected. The law governing all licensed stadia would need to be changed for that proposal to go ahead.

 

The Government’s current policy is that all-seater stadia are the best means to ensure the safety and security of fans at designated football matches in England and Wales. However the time is now right for us to reexamine that policy in light of the technological changes in stadium and seating design as well as the representations from both clubs and supporters on this issue.

 

We continue to work closely with the Sports Grounds Safety Authority to consider advances in technology and data on the issue.

 

The safety of spectators at sports grounds has always been of paramount importance for the Government. The all-seater policy was introduced in the top two divisions in the early 1990s, following a recommendation in Lord Justice Taylor’s Final Report into the Hillsborough Stadium Disaster.

 

All-seater stadiums have been a success. Benefits include:

● improved crowd management and crowd behaviour;

● modern, comfortable, and inviting facilities for spectators;

● increased inclusivity and diversity amongst those attending matches

- Premier League research has shown that the percentage of crowds attending Premier League matches from a Black and Minority Ethnic background continues to increase season-on-season, and is now at a record 16% (2014/2015 season); more women and children attending games helps to nurture the next generation of supporters - Premier League research has shown that a record 26% of match attendees are female, and that children's season ticket sales now make up 12% of all Premier League season ticket sales (2014/2015 season);

● enhanced security and policing to keep spectators safe;

● there have been fewer reported incidents and injuries to spectators, and

● Increased spectator attendances - by 60% - contributing to the future health of the game.

 

Given the success of all seater stadiums, the safety reasons for introducing the policy, and the enhancements that seated spectators have enjoyed, the Government would need strong evidence and rationale to change that policy.

The Government is aware of the calls from a wide range of interest groups including some football clubs and supporters’ groups to introduce standing areas for spectators at football matches in the top two divisions of English football.

We will continue to listen to supporters’ groups and other stakeholders who would like to see the reintroduction of standing at football in the top two tiers. The introduction of rail seating at Celtic Park and more recently at Shrewsbury Town FC informs the debate about the future of spectator accommodation at football matches. It is important that we have this debate and that it is informed by the evidence.

 

The Government is not complacent about spectator safety, nor are we complacent about the safety policies that have served spectators well for many years. But we acknowledge that policies must remain relevant and effective. Technology and stadium design have evolved since the all-seater policy was introduced. It is important that all the evidence and viewpoints are considered extremely carefully.

 

The Sports Minister looks forward to discussing at length the nuances and complexities of sports ground safety in Parliament later this month.

 

Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport

[Jimburst]

Sounds like an improvement in atmosphere won't be enough to get the go ahead, then.

[Yorkie]

Mmhmm. Am I being cynical by suggesting it'll depend on the revenue potential? If it's purely down to health and safety, the government probably wouldn't want to fix something that isn't broken, and I don't see why they'd even consider it.

[LFEE]

Surely the response from the government is missing the point. No one is talking about converting full stadiums back to safe standing. Just 10-20% of each one. The point is surely giving those who want to stand the choice.

[bowlingcrofty]

https://hansard.parliament.uk/commons/2018-06-25/debates/8A09C8B2-14D5-4E2D-8F3E-1D7FF3838818/FootballSafeStanding

[Yorkie]

Good few advocates for the decision to be devolved to individual clubs. Closing statement from the discussion.

 

At the moment, we do not have the data or the evidence to make a decision either way on the issue. What I am announcing today is that we will start the data and evidence collection, because as the hon. Gentleman says, it is clear that there are gaps in the injury data. We know that the current format of data collection does not allow people to specify some of the issues around the injuries that are happening at football matches.

 

I look forward to working closely with the Premier League, the English Football League and other organisations, including the Football Supporters Federation, which I met last week, to make progress together. I would like to thank the FSF, the Premier League, Mike Davis from Shrewsbury Town Supporters and the Plymouth Argyle management, who, in the middle of all the abuse, were kind and considerate in their conversations with me about the issue, which I appreciate. I also thank those at Spurs, and the chairman of Norwich City, for explaining the pragmatic approach that they are taking to ensure fans’ safety while still adhering to the law.

 

I acknowledge the evolution of stadium design, seating technology and modern crowd management approaches that has taken place in recent years. The data-gathering ​work will look at the impact of those changes and consider any existing data on the wider impact of introducing the type of rail seating accommodation used in Germany and elsewhere on attendances, ticket prices, the atmosphere, the diversity of supporters, fan behaviour, the management of various parts of the stadiums and, of course, safety.

[Dave]

[morla84]

Doubt we'll see it at St James Park for a while. If he won't pay for a couple of dead pigeons to be removed, he's never gonna fork out for rail seating

[Dave]

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/45414602