Imo should've brought on Shevchenko instead of Anelka. He's a penalty kick specialist who has missed one in the final of the CL... he would most likely had taken one in the first 6. Anelka isn't really an impact striker either, so not much to gain.
When i saw Terry step up I was like "wtf" but he definitely had the eye of the tiger. Looked like he was there for business, even the run-up was emphatic and confident.
As for Anelka... I agree everyone thought he would miss. Didn't look confident at all.. I thought the only way he'll score is if Van Der Sar goes the wrong way.