Ronaldo

When are we allowed to say he's not been good enough? When he's gone in the summer having been relegated as the most expensive defender in the club's history? The lad needs a season in a normally funtioning team, not this shower of s****. Who was the last defender a club paid £10m for who needed 12 months to settle in? His weaknesses, being getting turned, physical weakness & appalling defending when forwards are attacking the ball into the box, aren't anything that will be fixed by having time to settle. He needs to start looking like a good defender now. Errr...Vidic? tbh Liam's argument is flawed anyway as it's fair to say that most teams in a position to spend £10m on a defender generally have a decent enough midfield in place problem being that quite a lot of people said that all we needed was defenders, in spite of myself and one or two others saying the setup of the team with regard to being more offensive was the real weakness.] I'm pleased to see that you have now came around to my way of thinking. As for Coloccini, hes' OK, we have 3 good centre halfs at the club, but Taylor and Bassong are the best combination. Best combination based on one game? based on my judgement on the attritubes of the players, and what I prefer to see from my central defenders playing in this league that we play in. They've only played together once so it's impossible to state for if they're a better partnership than Coloccini and Bassong. I doubt we'll see that partnership again either unless Coloccini gets injured. I think playing together once is pretty much irrelevant to the judgement mate, I think they both have the most important attritubes to be first choice If you mean understanding between them, then that only comes through playing together. You really spoil yourself with your stupid opinions. Taylor a good defender. He continues giving away goals and basically looking out of his depth every game and you still consider him a good defender, honestly. Admit you were wrong about him like most have

rather have him on the wing tbh but I agree

Gallowgate

Berbatov is a lazy b******. berbatov tend to slow playing..... against barca... barca will rape their arse apart. I at at lot of this guy's posts.

Ofcourse there is exceptions. Guys like Phelps and especially Lewis are freaks. Tyson was 5'10 and 220lbs, he wasn't unathletic. Nolan is a normal bloke though, he isn't born with huge shoulders like these guys, and if he is 14st i would find it a little odd. Lennox Lewis's physique is studied by sports scientists to this day, an absolute genetic monster

in all seriousness, who told you that? blatantly isn't 14 stone like

no chance tbh, post 97, Shearer needed a pacey, workhorse striker next to him to be considered especially effective

N'zogbia not in the same class asGinola, or Robert. He is more like Olivier Bernard, (he thinks he is a better player than he really is) Bernard was a very good left-back until Souness convinced him that he wasn't

he basically has to set foot in the USA to make that a reality

that would be an ecu.... ahem ......YES!

rather have Joe Cole than Beckham in my team anyday, legs well and truly gone

rubbish, he's miles behind Joe Cole and Ashley Young for starters. Walcott and SWP are also more effective Blinkered by hatred, Joe Cole has never played consistently well for England. Walcott aside from his hattrick has done jack s***. SWP has very very rarely (almost never) performed for England. Ashley Young is the only one out of the four that has all the attributes to be successful for England and even he is not fully tested at the highest level. the premiership is the highest level

the 27 who've voted the latter have clearly never seen Mbia play

In all honesty whilst Given is a good keeper in terms of ability, he'll always be a wrong fit for a defence needing organisation and authority. See ya

Only one paper has claimed they value him at £18 million, every other source says £12 million. £8m plus Insomnia and a gentlemens agreement with citeh to leave veloso alone if we sell them given i suppose. lets hope it's someone other than doing the gentleman's agreeing "you dont have the arsehole to play Hart every week"

yes, because if Chelsea win it i am a grand richer and yes, because the idea of Man U or Liverpool winning a sandcastle competition makes me sick

Cisse and Martins, sounds good to me

You're not Bob Murray are you, he knew all about accounts. No I'm not. I think even Bob Murray would give up trying to explain the clubs finances to you though. he doesn't have to explain anything other than the success his club had when he ran it. Your talking about accounts, and I'm giving you a very successful accountant. If you think you know better than him how to run a football club........then again, you still back this DOF bollocks don't you , so you're detached from reality in both directions. Yes, that's exactly how it works, he was an accountant and since his club didn't get up to much that explains all you need to know. Just keep on borrowing a spending while avoiding answering all questions about where the moneys coming from is the way eh, Stevie. And I'm the one supposed to be detached from reality. so yo think that because Bob Murray did a good job for his club do you, matthew lad ? I suppose you do have an extra motivation here, other than being unable to admit your DOF bollocks has been shown up for what it is, and this is that your man Mike will be responsible for us playing in your local area of Bristol soon. Care to tell us when Arsenal and Liverpool are going bust, and why their supporters are so unhappy these days Arsenal are in very real danger of struglling financially, I imaigine they're in a posiiton to spend should the worse happen becasue they have been managed financially and not spent huge amounts. Liverpool on the other hand are a team waiting to collapse. and lets all hold hands, hum and hope they do

Guthrie is 21 and if he anything about him he'll force his way into the team sooner or later

Taylor, who's been at fault for a goal in the majority of the games he's played in is a better option than Coloccini? right

if they think he's worth £18m they're actually all insane

Based on what? As far as I can see he's been one of our most loyal players. He's been too good for Newcastle for quite a while now, I don't want him to leave but I won't slag him off for wanting to. Whether Man City should be his destination is questionable though. He did put a transfer request in once before after being left out for one game yes, during SBR's early days unless i'm mistaken

Anelka, Duff, Hypia

Veloso, Nolan, Guthrie and Barton = Butt sold to West Brom in the summer, fingers crossed

cheers for posting. I dont think he's a great player or owt but that's a sight i'm very very glad to see