He's a decent Premier League centre half, man. He's absolutely nowhere near as bad as you make out.
As for the Monday Night Football mention - we played on a Monday night just once in the second half of the season, against Arsenal. Granted, he had a poor game but against a team with the style of Arsenal he was basically doing the job of 3 men with Williamson & Dummett alongside him. We were barely noteworthy in the second half of the season so I'm doubtful Neville & Carragher even gave us much of a mention in the coverage of other teams games.
Mind the MNF against Everton when he was literally frightened of Lukaku wasn't good viewing.
He ran away from the ball ffs.
He's on about Colo.