Well he didn't give Carroll his debut, for a start.
Fair enough, I can't rememeber when Carroll's debut was. Not that it even matters who gave him his debut.
No, it doesn't. Unless you'd just asked 'Is there anything actually wrong in that?', of course.
I really meant was there anything that made Kinnear seem more of an idiot than we already knew.
Anyway, the idea that the guy deserves any "credit" is farcical - I agree with that.