Or ever.
In Chicago, The Globe, Fados and Gingers. If you can stand the saaaacer fans with their Wayne Rooney shirts at 8 in the morning, there are usually a few Newcastle supporters mixed in. In addition to FSC and FSC +, The Globe will also occasionally show streaming games on a projector, so that is probably your best bet.
I was in Chicago for the Man City match in October, didn't get a chance to go. I'm hoping to move there in the fall, so I'll definitely pay some visits.