Need to actually go out with the intention of having the ball. At the moment there's no point bringing Shelvey back in, playing Gayle, Perez or Ritchie.
This setup might aswell have Saivet and Colback sit infront of the back 4, Murphy, Atsu and Aarons in behind Joselu and Mitrovic for the long ball and counter. No point playing players who actually want the ball because the team's clearly set up to not have any of it.