David Edgar

Do not agree with these subs. Also, Bruce has now changed the system twice this half already. Just gonna lead to uncertainty between the players. Fucking moron.

Carroll getting a yellow card for his first foul? Victimised for not being a soft cunt

Laporte is SOFT.

Very realistic atmosphere. Sound department have done their homework.

Oh no, Bruce has shifted Schar into midfield. Oh dear.

Hayden? The correct answer was none.

Manquillo. His resurgence began 6 months before Rafa left imo. Kept it up though. people were just slow to pick up on it.

I think the argument against Bruce here is, given that we don't have Rondon and Perez anymore (who were very solid counter attackers in the 5-4-1 system), should we have taken a different approach? Or did Bruce trust Carroll to do a similar job to Rondon and ASM to slot in for Ayoze? You'd hope the pair could, to some extent. I don't know though. We're always going to be massive underdogs against Man City and to be still in the game now at 1-0 down is not that bad.

Tight, compact 5-4-1 defensive game playing on the counter? Is that not exactly what Rafa did when we won 2-1? I repeat, YOU know f##k all about football! Anyone who reads this post and thinks it is made by a human being knows fuck all about human beings.

Do you not think he's an intelligent footballer? I think we need to nail down what we're talking about. I think he is a fairly intelligent attacker, who has great technique, self confidence and pace. He is an amazing dribbler. Does he have the intelligence to modify his game in specific situations where it is better to say just clear the ball into a channel? I don't think so.

ASM is trying to do too much in dangerous positions. He's not smart enough to play any different.

Tight, compact 5-4-1 defensive game playing on the counter? Is that not exactly what Rafa did when we won 2-1?

Another ex-pro that has absolutely no business being a pundit. Thick as fucking mince. At most he can be on one of those fan video montage screens. I like him. Man City are amazing, what else is he meant to say? Maybe stop saying how sorry he feels for us as well as wanking over his old team and actually provide some insightful punditry?

We're getting the ball back with everyone so deep that Pep has clearly asked all his players within the vicinity to then just close the Newcastle player down ultra aggressively. They have no chance to do anything. Pep must just be sat there giggling like a little girl at how easy and utterly pathetic it was to prepare to go against this nonsense. "Same as Rafa's tactics" according to a few - I'm out of here. Cant deal with such simple brains. Care to outline the major difference between today and the 2-1 victory we had over City under Rafa? I'm sorry for wasting your massive brain's energy on this.

Another ex-pro that has absolutely no business being a pundit. Thick as fucking mince. At most he can be on one of those fan video montage screens.

Weeeeeeeeeeeeey, BBC have just realised we are still in the game.

Micah "I'm not biased" Richards is really biased.

We're still in the game. Just like the 2-1 win under Rafa.

Not too critical here. This approach won us a game with Rafa and got us a 2-2 with Bruce earlier this season. Have faith.

Schar pinning lasers already.

Carroll just killed Laporte by winning a header fairly.

Homegrown quota for when we're in the Champions League.

good evening everyone x

. Are you suggesting we log off and head to the beach?

How can that statement do anything but undermine the PL position seeing that it should be a confidential process?