Jump to content

Is Dennis Wise a disruptive influence? Or are the fans making him one?


The Prophet

Recommended Posts

If people are so unsure over what his duties are, or should be, and what he's currently doing, then how is it possible to apportion blame?  We're in the shit but just how much of it can 100%, incontrovertibly be traced back to him and him alone?

Link to post
Share on other sites

If people are so unsure over what his duties are, or should be, and what he's currently doing, then how is it possible to apportion blame?  We're in the s*** but just how much of it can 100%, incontrovertibly be traced back to him and him alone?

 

i blame ashley more than wise...

Link to post
Share on other sites

I was looking at Wise's current influence on proceeding rather than the influence he had on Keegan's departure.

 

The parties obviously didn't want to air it's dirty laundry in public and that's why we can only base our opinion on media speculation and the very breif statements we were given by the club and the LMA. Yet from these things people have managed to villainise and develop Wise as a hate figure. We really don't know if Wise himself was hugely influential in the departure himself. For me it's a case of people wanting a figure to point the finger at and Wise fits the bill perfectly.

 

And also you can't be a good scout based on who you've managed? What a load of bollocks.

Link to post
Share on other sites

There's absolutely nothing wrong in a club 'owning' the scouting system that it uses to identify players that are suitable for recruitment; in principle, therefore, an appointment like the Wise one is a sensible move. When a manager is recruited they usually appoint a large proportion of their staff and conversely, when they leave, take those staff, or a significant number of them, with them. Those staff should not include the recruiters of players; player recruitment should be a seamless, continuous affair.

 

Problems can arise when the scouts are working to different criteria to the manager in recruitment of senior players, either recruiting players of a type not wanted by the manager or recruiting too young players, or a combination of both those issues. The manager would have been recruited because they are successful, or it's perceived that they will be successful, because of the way that they go about their job, that is construct a team. In the recruitment of senior players (who, how many, for what position) it is clear that the manager's view should be paramount as it is they who will be judged on the basis of team performance which is not to say that their every wish should be granted.

 

This is what I believe happened to to us; on the last day of the season we recruited Xisco, who may be a talented player, and a free transfer who was soon crocked. We all knew what KK knew and that was we were short at full-back and, more than any other position, we have struggled there all season.

 

Wise is the director with responsibility for football matters and this clearly includes recruitment. He must bear the responsibiliy for player recruitment and this season has shown how short (no pun intended) he has come up in respect of that. If player recruitment had been right even Keegan going would not have led to the poorly constructed squad we now have (something which JFK chose to blame on previous managers which, in Keegan's case, was grossly unfair given the presence of Wise at the club from February onwards).

 

So, I think Wise's performance in a well thought-out position has been relatively poor and that has been disruptive. If he had performed better then Keegan may still have gone but the squad left behind would have been better balanced.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I was looking at Wise's current influence on proceeding rather than the influence he had on Keegan's departure.

 

The parties obviously didn't want to air it's dirty laundry in public and that's why we can only base our opinion on media speculation and the very breif statements we were given by the club and the LMA. Yet from these things people have managed to villainise and develop Wise as a hate figure. We really don't know if Wise himself was hugely influential in the departure himself. For me it's a case of people wanting a figure to point the finger at and Wise fits the bill perfectly.

 

And also you can't be a good scout based on who you've managed? What a load of bollocks.

 

wise wasn't a scout??? isn't he?? ne DoF right?

didn't DoF position at other club ex: real madrid. the position is higher than the manager certainly.

 

unfortunately i think keegan not aware of this situation when he first signed :no:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Anyone fancy defining his role with accuracy?

 

 

http://www.nufc.premiumtv.co.uk/page/NewsDetail/0,,10278~1227633,00.html

 

NEWCASTLE United announces that Dennis Wise has agreed to join the Club in the role of Executive Director (Football). Also joining the Club are Tony Jimenez as Vice President (Player Recruitment) and Jeff Vetere, who joins from Real Madrid in the position of Technical Co-ordinator.

 

Dennis will assist the Board on football-related matters, including the development of the Club's Academy and player recruitment. He will report to the Chairman. Tony and Jeff will also assist in player recruitment.

 

The arrival of these three new recruits follows on from the recent appointment of Kevin Keegan as manager. Kevin will be responsible for all matters related to the First Team.

 

Chairman Chris Mort said: "This is all part of the vision that recently helped us to secure Kevin Keegan's return to the Club as manager.

 

"Two of the conclusions of our strategic review, since acquiring the Club, were that the Club would benefit from having a football person involved at Board level, which it has not had historically, and that further senior resources are needed for recruiting players of the highest quality from this country and further afield.

 

"Dennis would like to move away from day-to-day football management to a Board role and, with his considerable energy and intelligence, we believe he will do very well in this new position.

 

"With Kevin able to devote his efforts to developing and running the first team squad, Dennis, Tony and Jeff will each help us to secure success for Newcastle United Football Club at all levels and for the long-term. One or two further key appointments will follow in the months ahead."

Link to post
Share on other sites

Anyone fancy defining his role with accuracy?

 

 

http://www.nufc.premiumtv.co.uk/page/NewsDetail/0,,10278~1227633,00.html

 

NEWCASTLE United announces that Dennis Wise has agreed to join the Club in the role of Executive Director (Football). Also joining the Club are Tony Jimenez as Vice President (Player Recruitment) and Jeff Vetere, who joins from Real Madrid in the position of Technical Co-ordinator.

 

Dennis will assist the Board on football-related matters, including the development of the Club's Academy and player recruitment. He will report to the Chairman.Tony and Jeff will also assist in player recruitment.

 

The arrival of these three new recruits follows on from the recent appointment of Kevin Keegan as manager. Kevin will be responsible for all matters related to the First Team.

 

Chairman Chris Mort said: "This is all part of the vision that recently helped us to secure Kevin Keegan's return to the Club as manager.

 

"Two of the conclusions of our strategic review, since acquiring the Club, were that the Club would benefit from having a football person involved at Board level, which it has not had historically, and that further senior resources are needed for recruiting players of the highest quality from this country and further afield.

 

"Dennis would like to move away from day-to-day football management to a Board role and, with his considerable energy and intelligence, we believe he will do very well in this new position.

 

"With Kevin able to devote his efforts to developing and running the first team squad, Dennis, Tony and Jeff will each help us to secure success for Newcastle United Football Club at all levels and for the long-term. One or two further key appointments will follow in the months ahead."

 

:buck2:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest fading star

Anyone fancy defining his role with accuracy?

 

 

http://www.nufc.premiumtv.co.uk/page/NewsDetail/0,,10278~1227633,00.html

 

NEWCASTLE United announces that Dennis Wise has agreed to join the Club in the role of Executive Director (Football). Also joining the Club are Tony Jimenez as Vice President (Player Recruitment) and Jeff Vetere, who joins from Real Madrid in the position of Technical Co-ordinator.

 

Dennis will assist the Board on football-related matters, including the development of the Club's Academy and player recruitment. He will report to the Chairman. Tony and Jeff will also assist in player recruitment.

 

The arrival of these three new recruits follows on from the recent appointment of Kevin Keegan as manager. Kevin will be responsible for all matters related to the First Team.

 

Chairman Chris Mort said: "This is all part of the vision that recently helped us to secure Kevin Keegan's return to the Club as manager.

 

"Two of the conclusions of our strategic review, since acquiring the Club, were that the Club would benefit from having a football person involved at Board level, which it has not had historically, and that further senior resources are needed for recruiting players of the highest quality from this country and further afield.

 

"Dennis would like to move away from day-to-day football management to a Board role and, with his considerable energy and extra thick skin, we believe he will do very well in this new position.

 

"With Kevin able to devote his efforts to developing and running the first team squad, Dennis, Tony and Jeff will each help us to secure success for Newcastle United Football Club at all levels and for the long-term. One or two further key appointments will follow in the months ahead."

What was the other part?

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Anyone fancy defining his role with accuracy?

 

 

http://www.nufc.premiumtv.co.uk/page/NewsDetail/0,,10278~1227633,00.html

 

NEWCASTLE United announces that Dennis Wise has agreed to join the Club in the role of Executive Director (Football). Also joining the Club are Tony Jimenez as Vice President (Player Recruitment) and Jeff Vetere, who joins from Real Madrid in the position of Technical Co-ordinator.

 

Dennis will assist the Board on football-related matters, including the development of the Club's Academy and player recruitment. He will report to the Chairman.Tony and Jeff will also assist in player recruitment.

 

The arrival of these three new recruits follows on from the recent appointment of Kevin Keegan as manager. Kevin will be responsible for all matters related to the First Team.

 

Chairman Chris Mort said: "This is all part of the vision that recently helped us to secure Kevin Keegan's return to the Club as manager.

 

"Two of the conclusions of our strategic review, since acquiring the Club, were that the Club would benefit from having a football person involved at Board level, which it has not had historically, and that further senior resources are needed for recruiting players of the highest quality from this country and further afield.

 

"Dennis would like to move away from day-to-day football management to a Board role and, with his considerable energy and intelligence, we believe he will do very well in this new position.

 

"With Kevin able to devote his efforts to developing and running the first team squad, Dennis, Tony and Jeff will each help us to secure success for Newcastle United Football Club at all levels and for the long-term. One or two further key appointments will follow in the months ahead."

 

:buck2:

 

:buck2: x 1000

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest guinness_fiend

To be fair, he seems to be going about his business without causing any obvious disruptions.  We are picking up promising youngsters.  I don't care if he was a nasty little sh!t when he was a player, he seems to be doing a decent job now and, as long as we continue to improve our Academy, long may he do so.

 

There is nothing to suggest that he interfered with any first team transfer activity, as everything mentioned in the media was pure speculation and has yet to be proved/disproved.

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Anyone fancy defining his role with accuracy?

 

I'm not convinced either of our managers since he came in can.

 

My interpretation is that he's primarily youth based but also suggests players for the first team as well.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Anyone fancy defining his role with accuracy?

 

I'm not convinced either of our managers since he came in can.

 

My interpretation is that he's primarily youth based but also suggests players for the first team as well.

 

 

so where does laying the law down to Kevin keegan, having turned up late smelling of drink come into it.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...