Jump to content

Recommended Posts

He's already reffed one Man Utd games this season and nothing was said about it.

 

Edit - Our referee against Bristol City was from Hartlepool (a small club that is close to Newcastle), nobody took issue with that one either.

[emoji38] Hartlepool's nowhere near Newcastle

 

In time taken, Hartlepool to Sunderland is just as far as Altrincham to Manchester. Hartlepool is also a relatively small club (like Altrincham) and Sunderland/Newcastle/Boro are the biggest teams near to Hartlepool.

 

Therefore, by the logic of "he lives close to Manchester, so he has some sort of feelings towards Man Utd" - the ref from Hartlepool should have some feelings towards Sunderland and never have ref'd our match.

 

I'm not saying it's right that he's been given this match, I just think it's ludicrous that people would go so over the top when his performances have never been bought into question when refereeing a Man Utd match and he has absolutely no feelings towards either club.

The logic is more that with Altrincham FC being so small and the city of Manchester being so close (a lot closer than any other major footballing town/city) that it's likely there's heavy support for them in the area. He likely grew up with Man Utd supporting friends, went out in Manchester growing etc.

 

Hartlepool has pretty much no connection to Newcastle or Sunderland. Middlesbrough - which is further away - has a bit though through it being the '2nd' derby.

 

You're right in that it's hard to draw lines and I could be way off about people from Altrincham, they may be collectively apathetic about the Manchester sides.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I reckon both non-league clubs will be happy there. Gateshead home to Newport if they see off Alfreton in the replay at home. Realistic chance of Round Two again.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest firetotheworks

 

 

He's already reffed one Man Utd games this season and nothing was said about it.

 

Edit - Our referee against Bristol City was from Hartlepool (a small club that is close to Newcastle), nobody took issue with that one either.

[emoji38] Hartlepool's nowhere near Newcastle

 

In time taken, Hartlepool to Sunderland is just as far as Altrincham to Manchester. Hartlepool is also a relatively small club (like Altrincham) and Sunderland/Newcastle/Boro are the biggest teams near to Hartlepool.

 

Therefore, by the logic of "he lives close to Manchester, so he has some sort of feelings towards Man Utd" - the ref from Hartlepool should have some feelings towards Sunderland and never have ref'd our match.

 

I'm not saying it's right that he's been given this match, I just think it's ludicrous that people would go so over the top when his performances have never been bought into question when refereeing a Man Utd match and he has absolutely no feelings towards either club.

 

It's also about the same distance to Liverpool, so it's moot imo.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...