Allan Saint-Maximin (now playing for Fenerbahce, on loan from Al-Ahli)

[LFEE]

8 hours ago, Sempiternal said:

I wouldn’t sell him personally, just need to look at Man United to see how buying attacking wide players is hard, both Sancho and Antony haven’t produced like ASM, and cost a lot more.

Couldn’t of put it more succinctly myself.

[Kanji]

If he learned how to pass and move like Miggy he’d take his game another level. Imagine him doing the ball carrying and moves + deciding nah I’m going to quickly lay it off and burn into space and receive it again. Would turn his game into the dynamo status. 

[Danh1]

Don’t want him to leave but just cannot rely on him being fit for a prolonged period of time.

 

Can understand why we would cash in on him if a good offer came in. Eddie was talking about the importance of trading in regards to FFP the other day in his presser.

 

Do hope that we sign a winger for each side if he does go. 

[WilliamPS]

8 hours ago, Sempiternal said:

I wouldn’t sell him personally, just need to look at Man United to see how buying attacking wide players is hard, both Sancho and Antony haven’t produced like ASM, and cost a lot more.

Agree, and any funds raised would go straight out the door on a replacement, with a big risk the replacement isn’t a success 

[r0cafella]

We have ambition now, so I’m not worried either way. 
 

I don’t fear losing players, I’m only excited about who we replace them with. 

 

 

Edited May 28, 2023 by r0cafella

[TheBrownBottle]

34 minutes ago, r0cafella said:

We have ambition now, so I’m not worried either way. 
 

I don’t fear losing players, I’m only exited about who we replace them with. 

Agreed.  I’m honestly unconcerned with any player being sold under the present regime.  Doesn’t worry me one iota - I’m confident any sale would be done with the notion that it is for the best for the club & team. 

[Viana]

Let’s be honest, Allan would be planning his exit route if the takeover hadn’t happened.

 

The same is true of Almiron (who I love). They both had busy agents that hadn’t quite found the stepping stone they were sold.

 

They’ve both changed their tune post takeover. The debate is whether it bothers you. The club is ambitious and now our goals align with their goals they want to stay. 
 

Personally, my only issue is Maxi’s injury record. 

[astraguy]

Think most people knew this tbh, who was after him ac milan or Inter? Class Class player who i'd never forget but to many injuries .would players really be told now they are up for sale mind?

 

 

Edited May 28, 2023 by astraguy

[Holloway]

Just want to see him healthy for an extended run of games from the start of next season, there's more to come from him in this set up

[Displayname]

4 hours ago, Viana said:

Let’s be honest, Allan would be planning his exit route if the takeover hadn’t happened.

 

The same is true of Almiron (who I love). They both had busy agents that hadn’t quite found the stepping stone they were sold.

 

They’ve both changed their tune post takeover. The debate is whether it bothers you. The club is ambitious and now our goals align with their goals they want to stay. 
 

Personally, my only issue is Maxi’s injury record. 

Any reasonable player with a semblence of ambition would try to get away from Mike Ashleys team that was managed by Steve Bruce.

[Viana]

Less time on Instagram more time working off the ball. 

[Newcastle Fan]

Hopefully he'll look fitter and better with a pre-season behind him.  Looked much slower in recent times.

[OverThere]

I would say keep and have him work on getting fitter. He offers something very different 

[joeyt]

Played really well today, especially first half

[astraguy]

Was Eddie or asm interviewed after the game?

[astraguy]

5 hours ago, astraguy said:

Was Eddie or asm interviewed after the game?

Eddie Howe on Saint-Maximin's future: “That will be dictated by Maxi himself. He has so much ability and he’s such an important player for us when he’s at his very best fitness-wise. He’s unique, there’s no one like him in the Premier League.” #NUFC

[Guest]

On 28/05/2023 at 04:35, Viana said:

Let’s be honest, Allan would be planning his exit route if the takeover hadn’t happened.

 

The same is true of Almiron (who I love). They both had busy agents that hadn’t quite found the stepping stone they were sold.

 

They’ve both changed their tune post takeover. The debate is whether it bothers you. The club is ambitious and now our goals align with their goals they want to stay. 
 

Personally, my only issue is Maxi’s injury record. 

 

Could say the same with Schar, Joelinton, Longstaff. I'd have been disappointed in them as players if they'd wanted to continue hanging around under an Ashley and Bruce NUFC. 

[wyn davies]

Personally I'd keep Maxi and move on Miggy , think Miggies had his time not always consistent .

[Barnes23]

No need to sell either, as things stand they are two of our best three wide players. 

[Weezertron]

I don't think we'd be able to bring in any better wide players for the money we'd get from Maxi and Miggy. So I vote keep. 

 

It's really tough thinking about how to go about this window. Eddie seemingly wants to keep a bunch of deadwood for morale, which is fine but you'll be tying some hands behind your back by doing so. 

[Guest]

Be a shame to see him go, he was in good form before his injury and started to look like he was considering to do some defensive work. Just a question if he can go injury free or not. 

[dave s]

keep him and bring another in. we have a fair few extra games next season. if he’s happy being benched often but still getting enough game time he’s still got skills we need

[Guest]

21 minutes ago, dave s said:

keep him and bring another in. we have a fair few extra games next season. if he’s happy being benched often but still getting enough game time he’s still got skills we need

 

I think he's the expendable one if we were to sign another left winger. We could still get £30m probably. Spend £40-50m on an upgrade/replacement and we still have Gordon as backup, Isak can play there, and we have the Jo-Joe combination available as well. 

[timeEd32]

Someone put this together to show how many assists he could/should have had: https://twitter.com/LucasNUFC1/status/1663556567348936704?s=20

 

Looks who's on the end of three of them ... Miggy owes him some drinks. 

[Kid Icarus]

3 minutes ago, timeEd32 said:

Someone put this together to show how many assists he could/should have had: https://twitter.com/LucasNUFC1/status/1663556567348936704?s=20

 

Looks who's on the end of three of them ... Miggy owes him some drinks. 

 

ASM, Willock, and even Gordon should have got more assists than they did. It's mad that we scored tons, finished 4th and yet were still very wasteful. 

 

 

Edited May 30, 2023 by Kid Icarus