Guest Martin Posted December 21, 2006 Share Posted December 21, 2006 Given - Top of the class, keep it up. If we din't have this wonderkeeper we would be f****d. Only slight criticism is commanding of the box. A Nobby - Found a new lease of life at RB, the verdict is still out wether he is good enough against the really top sides but certainly kept Robben quiet last night. B Taylor - Was looking quite good in drama class but has flourished lately. Most improved player of the first half. Concentration levels have rocketed. Looking like the future armband wearer we all hoped he would, keep it up! B+ Ramage - Being able to head a ball well does not a defender make. Taylor is helping him raise his game. Jury is still out. Quality defensive signing in January would see you benched. C Huntington - New arrival! Young, keen. Good header of the ball. Should bulk out a bit. C- Milner - We were given a very good report by your last placement (Villa) and on the strength of that you should be doing a lot better! Need to work on your finishing if you are going to be an asset to this class. C Butt - That transfer to Birmingham showed you what a truly crap team are all about. Came back with a little more respect for Newcastle and it shows. Linchpin for the team ATM. Keep it up B+ Emre - Being fantastic against lesser opposition is only half the job. It would be nice to see you perform more against the top sides. More attention on the set pieces please. Or let someone else take them. B- Duff - A very decent report from your old place, seems not to have transferred here. Problems with injury and inconsistancy. We know you can do it. Let's see it! C+ Sibierski - We didn't hold out much hope when you came to us, but you have put the ball in the net. You also fill the role of a box player, which we desperately require. However despite your enthusiasm we fear that, like Ramage, a quality 18 yard poacher with some height will see you relegated to the bench. B Martins - I see you as the "Rooney/Bellamy/Defoe" type player for us. Quick, slippery and technicaly gifted. Genuinely two footed. You need an 18 yard box player with you to flourish. We'll see the best of you starting from next season I'll wager. B+ Luque - Afraid it just hasn't worked out for you here. Whether it be the pace of the Premiership, bad management or you own application. Another expensive mistake. E (for embarracement) Babayaro, Carr, Bramble, Moore, Ameobi, Bernard - Not at the required level for this club! Zog, Owen, Krull, Harper - unlucky boys hope to see you back soon. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!Register a new account
Already have an account? Sign in here.Sign In Now