Joe Willock

[andycap]

Got to be after atleast 30 million for him. 

We do tend to underate our players Longstaff aswell we are a top end team now not a relegation threatened team. 

So Willock and Longstaff should fetch a decent fee. 

[McCormick]

I like Willock, but I feel he has 3 games now to save his Newcastle career.
 

At his best he’s an erratic and speedy ball-carrying threat who gets into good goal scoring positions. At his worst though he’s far too clumsy in possession and very tactically naive. If we can somehow replace him with Ramsey and make a PSR profit; that’d be too good to turn down.

 

Personally speaking, I’m rooting for the guy.

[Miggys First Goal]

Sell please. 

[Menace]

Yeah I think the time has come to sell him.

 

Comes back from injury > few games to get up to speed, still underperforms > gets injured again

[JT24]

Can’t be relied upon. Certainly on my list to sell.

 

Sad to see but think this is a summer where we have to kick on and get in players who can contribute when we have 2 games a week. 

[nufc123]

If we can get some money sell. Hes a nice guy but he cant be trusted.

[Unbelievable]

9 minutes ago, Menace said:

Yeah I think the time has come to sell him.

 

Comes back from injury > few games to get up to speed, still underperforms > gets injured again

The circle of Willock and Wilson™

 

 

Edited Sunday at 10:25 by Unbelievable

[Displayname]

Ship off to Saudi. All he got left is his name.

[Sibierski]

If we were undecided as a club if Willock should be sold, this month has made up their minds IMO. 
 

Not good enough for XI but then not reliable enough as a squad option.

[David Edgar]

£75m to Saudi please. 

[Nucasol]

West Ham or Palace. He’s stuck together with cheese strings, super noodles and broken biscuits.

[The College Dropout]

What’s wrong with him?

[M1tche]

Annoyingly, today was a very Joe Willock type of game in the 2nd half

[Optimistic Nut]

Hard being critical of anything the season we're having, but when he's played he's not been great, and now injured again. Just need to get what money we can and move on. 

[Nucasol]

Touch and go for weekend, not ruled out according to Eddie.

[The College Dropout]

I never understood trying to sell a relatively young player on a low-ebb for cheap unless desperate for money.

[r0cafella]

32 minutes ago, The College Dropout said:

I never understood trying to sell a relatively young player on a low-ebb for cheap unless desperate for money.

Injury prone contract expiring, not that young anymore etc. 

[TRon]

5 minutes ago, r0cafella said:

Injury prone contract expiring, not that young anymore etc. 

 

When is his contract expiring?

 

 

[TRon]

Never mind, just checked and there's a couple of years left so not going to be leaving for a pittance.

[r0cafella]

21 minutes ago, TRon said:

Never mind, just checked and there's a couple of years left so not going to be leaving for a pittance.

Yeah so basically this summer it's shit or get off the pot. 

 

It's a no brainer sale for me, obviously contingent upon us replacing him. 

[Displayname]

1 hour ago, The College Dropout said:

I never understood trying to sell a relatively young player on a low-ebb for cheap unless desperate for money.

When the "low-ebb" has lasted longer than his high performing period then yes.

[TRon]

29 minutes ago, r0cafella said:

Yeah so basically this summer it's shit or get off the pot. 

 

It's a no brainer sale for me, obviously contingent upon us replacing him. 

 

Agree, already said last week that I have no problem selling Willock and using that money to buy an understudy for Joelinton. Willock has a lot of attributes, but he's out for long periods, then when he does come back in he's had little impact.

[James]

He’d be perfect for Palace, West Ham or Spurs

[The College Dropout]

1 hour ago, r0cafella said:

Injury prone contract expiring, not that young anymore etc. 

2 years left.

 

I would send him out on loan and extend the contract by a year to try and increase his value. Ideal world.

[r0cafella]

2 hours ago, The College Dropout said:

2 years left.

 

I would send him out on loan and extend the contract by a year to try and increase his value. Ideal world.

Your solution makes little sense in practical terms. If you send him out on loan we need a replacement, may as well sell him and buy a replacement for him.